Transcript
Machine draft Unreviewed Deepgram nova-2 output. Speakers are automatically assigned and may need checking against the recording.
-
0:01
Steve Field
My name's David Carr. I live in Armendar,
-
0:05
and I'm here with Steve Phil who lives in Uralla.
-
0:09
And today is the 10/27/2012,
-
0:13
and we're in Yooralla,
-
0:15
to record,
-
0:16
as part of the Yooralla Steve project,
-
0:20
and we're gonna talk about our involvement
-
0:22
in revegetation
-
0:23
and dieback,
-
0:25
all those sorts of things.
-
0:29
So I'm gonna get to start. I'm gonna talk about... I... When I was,
-
0:34
I tell you my my involvement with dieback
-
0:38
in 1977,
-
0:40
I was in
-
0:41
scouts
-
0:43
or features or something in Tamworth.
-
0:45
The dieback was a really big thing then. There was, you know, all the
-
0:49
the big news stories in the paper every day, and and,
-
0:53
they were getting the dieback fighting fund going and, you know, we heard about it all the time.
-
0:58
And so I did a project from from one of my scat badges of dieback,
-
1:03
and and I've still got it. It's it's terrible to see what my grandma was like when I was that age,
-
1:09
but but I've got all these clippings from the newspaper of, about dieback, and I was really,
-
1:15
horrified about it. We used to drive up here to Glen Iris all the time and see my
-
1:19
mother's family.
-
1:21
You know, we'd see what we'd driven through as forest for years just
-
1:26
disappearing. It was fairly traumatic. So I think that that might have been a bit of a trigger for me getting involved in,
-
1:32
you know, all this greedy stuff later in life.
-
1:36
And then
-
1:38
and then I... You know, by the time I came up here
-
1:41
and to River to go to uni and it was sort of still
-
1:44
in the thick of it. So I just kept on that involvement.
-
1:49
But but you were at it... You were working at
-
1:52
Eastlake with Gordon Williams.
-
1:54
David Carr
Yeah. I I think I started there in about nineteen ninety,
-
1:58
eighty nine, ninety.
-
2:01
And
-
2:02
I'd I'd been a stockman on other places that didn't have the dieback.
-
2:06
And
-
2:08
when I went out out to Gordon's, Gordon was pretty active in
-
2:11
in trying to get that sort of thing fixed up as far as his
-
2:15
his own property was go... Was concerned.
-
2:18
And he used to have...
-
2:20
One of my roles out there, I should say, was,
-
2:24
helping anybody that wanted to go out there and learn how to
-
2:28
do trials with trees or shrubs or whatever.
-
2:31
I used to have prepare all the sites for them. That was that was one of my jobs. That's where I I sort of... I really cut my teeth because I saw I saw every single
-
2:40
trial that was ever done was done out at Eastlake. And I saw what worked and I saw what didn't work. And... So David Curtis'
-
2:48
direct selling trials... That was one that was one... I think that was one of the very first things I ever did out there. First time it was within about a week
-
2:55
of starting work there.
-
2:57
And that was considered to be a failure
-
3:00
at the time. Yeah. Well, they they went through and and, and it wasn't...
-
3:06
We got no rain. We put it all in. We got absolutely no rain. And I can remember Gordon coming back from the paddock there one day and he said, oh, well, it was a waste of time, wouldn't it? You know?
-
3:15
We'll have to go back and redo it at some point.
-
3:18
And we never ever got back there because it just keep Arding. And I think about six months later, we went up there and it was
-
3:24
just covered. Yeah. Just
-
3:26
Bundarra, you know, we we did the... We
-
3:29
sort of stumbled on doing the right thing, I think. I went out I went out there with David,
-
3:33
Steve Field
must have been 95 or
-
3:36
something, to have a look and do some measurements, and it was like a fence. Yeah. But there was a ceiling every
-
3:42
two centimeters. Yeah. And these silver wattles were, like, River meters high and two centimeters crossed at the base. Yeah. Yeah. They were. Yeah.
-
3:50
David Carr
So that that was that was a pretty good use for that hill because all I've ever had before, that was fly blown sheep.
-
3:56
It just... It was just... I just covered in logs
-
4:00
Yeah. And you couldn't get round.
-
4:02
And so all the fly by sheep is to end up going up there to die. Right. Mostly when Maybe it's wild or Greece, they will. Oh, maybe. All the fertilizer.
-
4:11
Steve Field
Yeah. But I So God was right. He know he was he was
-
4:14
he was one of the pioneers too. Oh, for sure. He he was,
-
4:18
David Carr
his grand plan, I think, was to
-
4:21
cover about 3%
-
4:23
of his property, which doesn't sound very much. Yeah. But he had, there was 3,300
-
4:29
acres, I think.
-
4:31
And we worked... I worked there for,
-
4:35
at least ten years,
-
4:37
and we planted every year. And I don't think we broke 1% and we put trees everywhere.
-
4:42
Steve Field
Yeah.
-
4:43
Do you remember there there'd be,
-
4:46
a lot of dieback,
-
4:48
David Carr
like, trees that were killed from dieback on this place? I missed it. I I just... I was on another property further south where we didn't get the River. Yeah. It just didn't happen.
-
4:58
And then when I came up here, it had already happened. So to me, it was just like, you know, it's a pity there's a lot of dead trees standing in the paddock, but I never saw them die. Yeah.
-
5:07
Steve Field
Because a lot of a lot of people clean them up fairly quickly. Yeah. Because you look at the landscape now and you think the ice has been cleared for a long time.
-
5:16
But apart from a few patties, like there's one down there just as all the riders who nearly get to walker
-
5:22
that's got... Still got a lot of standing dead trees,
-
5:27
but they used to be everywhere.
-
5:29
I I first came up here in '84
-
5:32
to go to go to uni, and
-
5:35
there was a lot of... Still a lot of dead trees standing in paddocks around. But over those... Over the next sort of ten years, they... A lot of that got cleaned up and pushed River, and there was like there was no sign that they'd River been Yeah. Forest there.
-
5:50
David Carr
Yeah. Well, I thought they did
-
5:52
it. It's all pushed up and burned. Yeah.
-
5:55
Thousands and thousands of trees. Yeah. Actually, they were good firewood. I don't know why
-
5:59
he wouldn't let anybody just go out there and do that. We didn't get the firewood out of there.
-
6:04
So Well, that'd be yellow boxes, I mean? Yeah. Yeah. Yellow box and red gum.
-
6:09
Yeah. Everywhere out
-
6:11
there.
-
6:12
But
-
6:12
that's just... That was just the the thing at the time was get it get it cleaned up and
-
6:17
so you're not looking at a mess, I suppose. Yeah.
-
6:20
But I do remember talking to talking to people out there when they would come out, you know, the the scientific side of things like yourself and Dave Curtis and,
-
6:30
Richard Morsley and and then... And
-
6:33
I was always pretty cynical about it, I think, because I saw failures and I and I sort of saw the academic side of it.
-
6:42
And, oh, no. Things just sort of didn't quite gel. And I remember saying to,
-
6:46
to somebody, I won't mention their name, but I I thought that,
-
6:52
this is never ever gonna get fixed with an altruistic
-
6:55
just just through pure altruism. It was never never gonna work because
-
6:59
the, you know,
-
7:01
the people's enthusiasm
-
7:03
wanes very quickly. They might be all,
-
7:06
you know, rush and tear for a few days and then that's the end of it. And that needs us... That needs a financial base behind it. Yeah. And that's why that's why when when I lost my job out there, which is basically just through wool prices
-
7:20
Oh, yeah. You know, downturn in wool prices when the floor price was That's right. Was jacked out. And they had that big,
-
7:27
stockpile. They did. Yeah. And,
-
7:29
and that that cost me my job. I mean, fortunately, it didn't cost me the house I was living in, but
-
7:35
but then I got the opportunity
-
7:37
to start growing trees. I was growing them beforehand, but then I thought I'd really like to have a crack at this and see if I can't make a business out of it.
-
7:46
So have you grown them for Gordon? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Only for a year or two. Yeah. And I was pretty ordinary. Yeah.
-
7:53
Like, Jart used to do a lot of the propagation because
-
7:56
my big fat fingers
-
7:58
used to kill more than they David.
-
8:00
But at the end of the day, I I I worked out that I had to learn how to do it myself. So I just bit the bullet and sort of really taught myself how to not be rough and
-
8:08
how to get some plants to live. How to get delicate figures. Yeah.
-
8:13
So that was where I started and then eventually we got, we just moved into town.
-
8:19
Yeah. And that's... I think that that was around about the time that Janet moved into the Greening Australia office. Yeah. Which is about the time I started with Greening Australia.
-
8:27
Steve Field
Right. Because I I went to Sydney for a couple of years.
-
8:31
Sydney? Yeah.
-
8:32
Because,
-
8:34
my wife was,
-
8:36
Arding there. So we had two years in Sydney, and then
-
8:39
we came back because I got that job with Greening Australia
-
8:42
in 1994
-
8:44
with David Curtis
-
8:46
and Janet and
-
8:48
Bruce Arding, and that was that was the office.
-
8:51
Orchard
-
8:54
There was nobody else in it? I thought there was other Oh, there were eventually, but that... That's who it started with. Right. Yeah. And it was like that... Up until that point, it had been David
-
9:03
by himself. Yeah. But,
-
9:07
yeah, there was all those other people like
-
9:09
Nick Reid and Chris Nodoli doing
-
9:12
their bits and pieces Bundarra Richard Borsley
-
9:15
doing his stuff. Yeah.
-
9:17
Of course, all
-
9:19
the landholders and the tailors,
-
9:21
David Carr
those sort of people. Then there was a Treefest the tree group
-
9:24
actually came from that, didn't it? Tree group started in '84.
-
9:29
Steve Field
So it preceded all that Green Australia stuff, and it was it was a direct response to dieback
-
9:36
because it was...
-
9:38
No. It must Steve been 8082
-
9:40
because it's our thirtieth year this year Right. For the tree group. And, you know, that was just volunteers
-
9:47
growing stuff
-
9:49
in milk cartons and
-
9:51
giving them away to farmers or going out and doing Yeah. Voluntary plantings. I can remember.
-
9:56
David Carr
I mean, we were the recipients Yeah. Yeah. That's right. Of some of that Steve, and I I... That's when I first met,
-
10:03
Carr O'Keefe.
-
10:04
Yeah. And,
-
10:07
Steve Field
yeah. So he worked at... He he worked a bit with Mike or
-
10:10
David Carr
Yeah.
-
10:14
I I... We were really getting serious at the... At around about the same point that you moved over
-
10:20
to Mann Steve.
-
10:22
The tree group moved over to Oh, yeah. Yeah. That was when we... That that was a... I can I can just sort of remember that that was about the time that we were getting
-
10:31
going as well? Yeah. And I worked with... I worked... I collaborated with Mike on a few things,
-
10:36
and,
-
10:38
and I was fortunate enough to win a couple of pretty reasonable contracts that I shared around between all the growers. Yeah. And that sort of sort of helped everybody.
-
10:50
So that was that was pretty interesting. Yeah. I had I had fond memories of Mike. Yeah. He was he was a good good good friend and, you know, a bit of a confidant. We'd used to be able
-
11:00
to chew the fat and tell some lies, I suppose. Yeah. She bottles red wine. Yeah. As was as was his one. Yeah.
-
11:07
Steve Field
That's funny. That's Steve a legacy of the
-
11:10
the trade group because, you know, president of the trade group. And
-
11:15
there's still, you know, red wine at committee
-
11:18
meetings, and it goes back to, you know, Mike and...
-
11:23
They're all a bunch of business, I think.
-
11:25
David Carr
Yeah.
-
11:26
Well, I mean, I suppose you gotta remember your roots. They were all they were all volunteer roots, weren't they? So Yeah. And it was all about having fun while you're doing it. Wasn't... They didn't really get too miserable about No. Dieback and everything. So... No.
-
11:39
No. Well...
-
11:40
Yeah. Well, it's... That's sort of... That's... That was a very similar place to where we started. And and I suppose for a while, we were a lot like the ambulatory group.
-
11:50
Well, for about, maybe a year or so, we we were very similar in in our nature.
-
11:57
And then
-
11:58
and then we ended up sort of heading off on a different on a different course again, which was good for us. Yeah. And good... And and I'd... And, you know, by extension, good for them too. I mean, we were not
-
12:10
we were not swimming in each other's pool Yeah. Sort of thing.
-
12:14
Steve Field
Do you reckon that's why there's still you
-
12:17
know, five,
-
12:19
commercial foam tree nurseries on
-
12:21
the tableings that people sort
-
12:23
of foundry niche and differentiated a bit? You know, like, you got
-
12:27
Chris Emily, he's just,
-
12:30
you know, plugged away,
-
12:31
just trees and just planting.
-
12:33
Tree groups done all sorts of stuff. Yeah.
-
12:36
David Carr
Well, certainly, the... I think the
-
12:39
I think the tree the tree group
-
12:41
was first and they...
-
12:43
I don't know whether... Are they all that much different in the art of what they were, do you think?
-
12:49
Steve Field
A lot more,
-
12:52
you know, probably no. We we were just looking at it the other day. Our firm trees
-
12:56
are really... Over the last couple of years, it's been a really small part of the business, and a lot of it's been retail
-
13:02
and
-
13:04
consulting
-
13:05
Mhmm. Jobs Bundarra,
-
13:07
commercial clients, you know, like
-
13:10
housing developments
-
13:12
or industrial
-
13:13
developments. But... So we're actually trying to move back to farm trees
-
13:18
David Carr
on the tableauge a bit more. So would you would you say yourselves as the,
-
13:22
as the horticultural version of
-
13:24
a plastic surgeon that does 90% of his work. So,
-
13:28
you know, giving giving
-
13:30
rich ladies,
-
13:32
you know, face... Face Steve so that you can afford to do the to do the cosmetic surgery on on less fortunate.
-
13:39
Steve Field
Yeah.
-
13:40
Well, I suppose so. Yeah. That's... You know, we always...
-
13:44
You know, anytime we go into something new... So we just got into veggie seedlings this year,
-
13:50
and it's called gangbusters.
-
13:52
And and when we did it, when Rob started doing it, we had to say, hang on. You know, tree group, not the vegetable seedlings group.
-
14:00
And... But we have a test that that sort of says if it's
-
14:04
if it's not our mission, you know, it's not what we're there for. It's gotta generate enough profit to be put back into that. So,
-
14:11
yeah, you're you're probably right. So we're
-
14:14
we're doing these, bird jobs around the place for
-
14:17
David Carr
But but that's something... There's nothing wrong with that. No. No. I don't I don't see that. I think I think that a certain amount of business
-
14:24
skills have to come in
-
14:26
to do... To achieve your ends. You know what I mean? There's... If the government's not helping you, then you have, you know, or not giving you the support that you need to
-
14:35
to fulfill your aims. Yeah.
-
14:38
Then, you know, you're not selling your you're not selling your soul. Well, it's just a matter of,
-
14:43
you know, changing changing a few little directions and tweaking your business. And that's that's a good that's a good thing. I I find that I'm forever doing it. Yeah.
-
14:52
Steve Field
Well, for us, for for... As as a community group, and it was the same with Greening Australia.
-
14:57
You,
-
14:58
you... You'd say dependent on,
-
15:03
you're not so much selling
-
15:05
services. You're not selling, like, you know, just relying on trees. You... You've gotta come up with ideas and then sell that idea to somebody and get them to pay for it.
-
15:13
And,
-
15:14
and that,
-
15:15
you know, it's always boom and bust. So sometimes
-
15:19
with creating Australia, we we always just say, is this taxi driving?
-
15:22
You know? Because we we figured we could go and get a job. We could go by a taxi. We could make heaps of money, but it would actually have nothing to do with... It would do nothing for the environment. Yeah. So we... That was our test, you know, for things. And we ended up having to do a bit of taxi driving sometimes,
-
15:39
not literally, but we're doing,
-
15:41
you know, tourist projects and things like that just when there was nothing else foundry, just so you Carr keep
-
15:48
really key Steve
-
15:49
David Carr
so that when there was something that you needed, you know, once the money around, you Carr actually say, well, we've got the Steve to do it. Well, that's exactly the flexibility that you need in the business. Oh, yeah. It's not all... It's it's not all, you know, cream and jam. It's sometimes you just gotta go out and graft. Yeah. Yeah. That's right. I I find I find we do the same thing. Yeah. You know,
-
16:12
it's... Otherwise, you you get locked you get locked in really tight and you've got no flexibility and you've got no way of moving and
-
16:19
cash flow stops.
-
16:21
I mean, I don't have I don't have anybody helping me with any funding really. No.
-
16:26
And and so we only get one bite of the cherry. We...
-
16:31
A few weeks without cash flow and we're in we're in strife. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, Qantas can only last two weeks without cash flow. Yeah. You can imagine what,
-
16:39
you know, the rest of us are... Aren't gonna last very long either. The the... So... A bit of credit.
-
16:45
Steve Field
So how much you... What you do is,
-
16:48
I mean, altruistic, but
-
16:51
you you must be doing this because you're passionate about it rather than
-
16:55
David Carr
No. I don't do it I don't do it for the money.
-
16:57
What's that? I don't do it for the money. No. I do I do do it for the lifestyle. I have a I have a lifestyle.
-
17:03
And even the guys that work for me have a lifestyle and we're and we're all happy to we're all happy to sort of, fit within that.
-
17:11
We all make a reasonable living. Don't get me wrong. I mean, we're not we're not
-
17:15
as poor as churchmen or anything like that. But,
-
17:19
there's some things that we do for nothing.
-
17:22
Quite a quite a bit of it around Europe. Yeah. You know, and I don't know. I just don't think anybody River even notices. I certainly don't...
-
17:31
You know, it's just what you do. Or any... Anybody that... Anybody in your relatives comes to me asking for for plants for the kindergartens or whatever, They just they just get those for free. Yeah. And...
-
17:42
Steve Field
So that's your community service instead of joining right for you. Yeah. Something like that. Mhmm. Yeah. Well, after after the,
-
17:52
David Carr
after that planting the koalas Arding, when I was down there, we're planting the trees for the koalas, probably better better description.
-
18:00
Steve Field
Plenty koalas.
-
18:01
David Carr
I, yeah, I realized that we we planted 60 trees or or the the community did.
-
18:07
That's not gonna go anywhere.
-
18:10
I mean, Dinesh would clean those up in probably six weeks.
-
18:15
And so I said to...
-
18:18
Well, I I just said to...
-
18:21
Oh, I can't think of a name.
-
18:24
Steve Field
Steve.
-
18:25
David Carr
Yeah. And,
-
18:27
I just made an offer. I said, look. I've got... I'll give you 500 trees if you can find find somebody to put them. And Charlie Rudd was there.
-
18:35
And Charlie said, oh, well, you can put them up on my block.
-
18:38
So okay. Well, that sounds pretty good. So I've got the trees and we've got the block.
-
18:42
And then Steph popped up and she said, well, we'll provide the tractor.
-
18:46
So I went up. Charlie got it slashed. I went up and sprayed it. I'd say in the next week or two, it'll be all ripped up. They'll use our meander
-
18:54
and we'll go and plant 500 trees. Yeah.
-
18:58
It all it all took less than five minutes to organize. Yeah. That's fantastic.
-
19:02
You know? And and now they will have... She'll have 500 trees to start selecting from, which will be a whole lot better than 60.
-
19:10
Yeah. Yeah. And they can leave those 60 alone.
-
19:13
Steve Field
On the creek. On the creek.... At least the flowers there.
-
19:17
David Carr
Well, maybe. I don't know. But I I just didn't see that I didn't see that the 60 trays were really gonna be of any value. Yeah. Yeah.
-
19:25
Steve Field
Yeah. It's a bit tough for her. She's got a...
-
19:29
When you hear about how hard it is for them to get loops and they gotta do it twice a day. Yeah. I know. That's a full time job, isn't it? It is. I don't think she gets a bit paid, does she? No. No.
-
19:40
No. No. It's amazing what people do.
-
19:43
For that It's all about passion, isn't it? It is. But for for her as well.
-
19:47
David Carr
Yeah.
-
19:48
Steve Field
It's interesting you talk about lifestyle because that's probably what I do for her as well.
-
19:53
There's there... You know, sometimes there's a bit of money in it, but
-
19:56
it's always about... Like, I've just spent three days out around,
-
20:01
you know, with the Colorado, and,
-
20:06
and Ashley,
-
20:07
and everywhere,
-
20:08
and just poking around on roadsides and
-
20:11
looking at plants and talking to people
-
20:14
and giving people ideas and,
-
20:16
David Carr
you know, it's good fun. I love it. I like doing that. I love it. Yeah. The... Well, now
-
20:23
this year, we've we've
-
20:25
switched over a bit as well where...
-
20:27
And... Well, as you're aware. And we're doing we're doing a bit more out there collecting and
-
20:33
I know the two guys that work for me just love it. They're, you know, they're off their chops when they get out of the Carr. That's I I never thought I'd see that sort of excitement,
-
20:42
you know, but Ben's...
-
20:44
He's all over it. That's great, isn't it? It is. It is. Because he used to hate that country out there. Yeah. He was always like, oh, I'm still flat.
-
20:51
Well, I think so. You know, now he's got his eyes open to realize it's just how much there is,
-
20:57
around the place. So the the passion for those two guys is is right up there at the moment.
-
21:04
And and it's just
-
21:06
it's just a unique experience, I suppose. So that's your succession plan. You got your next generation excited? Yeah. Yeah. I don't think there'd be any problems with a succession plan for that. You know, they... Like I say, it's,
-
21:20
it it... Now the the...
-
21:22
Probably the difficult part is gonna be actually
-
21:25
coming up to actually sell those ideas.
-
21:28
Yeah. Yeah. So sell that as a,
-
21:30
as an opportunity for copies.
-
21:35
I think that might take me Bundarra couple of years, to be honest with you. Yeah. Well, some people Carr real good. You know?
-
21:42
Steve Field
And it's,
-
21:44
I mean, out there, it's like... Yeah. I read more and that sort of area. It's like they're
-
21:48
twenty years behind
-
21:50
what's hap... What happened on the table there. It's like,
-
21:53
if you if you just went knocked on any farmer's door on the table there, it's now... Carr can be a pretty high chance
-
21:59
that if you offer them some trees to plant, they'll get you alright.
-
22:03
Whereas
-
22:04
twenty years ago, it was like,
-
22:06
no way.
-
22:08
There would have been a few
-
22:10
crazies like,
-
22:12
you know, Gordon and John Taylor and those sort of people who are into trees. I reckon it sort of turned around that it's the other way there that they'd be. Don't you think that the New England is the home of tree planting? Well, I reckon we picked all our stuff up off Victoria because, like, Victoria was like another ten years ahead of us. Okay.
-
22:32
So did you ever go on those
-
22:34
bus tours that...
-
22:36
Magical mystery tours with Dave Curtis?
-
22:38
David Carr
No. No. I don't think I was in the acting fraternity.
-
22:42
Steve Field
So I I went down,
-
22:45
He put together
-
22:47
a itinerary to go look at all these real pioneering tree tree planters in Victoria, the Potter Carr, and,
-
22:55
John Fenton
-
22:56
out at Hamilton.
-
22:58
And, I missed the bus tour, but I I went
-
23:02
sort of a... On a conference and then sort of hung around and went and visited all these Carr. And
-
23:07
they've been doing
-
23:09
pretty much the same sort of stuff, you know, tree groups,
-
23:14
getting natives into
-
23:15
plantings,
-
23:16
direct seeding,
-
23:18
all that sort of Steve, but they sort of started in the early seventies
-
23:22
doing that
-
23:23
because basically that landscape was
-
23:26
over clean debuggery and, you know, they
-
23:29
they were...
-
23:30
Wasn't dieback that kicked it off for them. It was just,
-
23:33
you know, drought, desolation,
-
23:36
David Carr
horrible Mhmm. Leave. I suppose that country down there was settled
-
23:40
long before up here too, wasn't it? I mean, places like Ballarat and Yeah. And what have you, they they sort of have a much older...
-
23:48
Steve Field
I don't know if it's older. I think it was just probably...
-
23:51
This is a small Steve,
-
23:53
and and the arid zones sort of come in
-
23:56
pretty tight to the coast in Victoria and South Australia,
-
24:00
that there was lots of people in a smaller area.
-
24:03
Whereas I think New South Wales is a lot more space for people. Yeah. I don't know.
-
24:08
But you just look at... Like, you go down there now
-
24:12
and you realize how lucky we are because
-
24:15
there's parts that... You know, you go out through the Western slopes and then down into Victoria, there's huge areas where there's just nothing. There's just no
-
24:23
no Treefest. Well, there's just these thin little strips up roadside.
-
24:27
You know, we still got
-
24:28
quite a bit. Even out of it.
-
24:32
But
-
24:34
I remember going to John Fenton's place
-
24:36
in 1996.
-
24:39
David Carr
You know?
-
24:40
He he was one of the... I think I've seen his name on a on a few things, but I don't know anything about it. So he was a farmer,
-
24:47
Steve Field
on a,
-
24:48
you know, on
-
24:50
the Western Plains in,
-
24:53
Victoria, you know, the
-
24:55
the... Where Malcolm Fraser is from out that way,
-
24:58
Hamilton. Alright. And he was a, you know, a farm wall grower. And,
-
25:04
he said he he went to one of his neighbors in a drought,
-
25:09
you know, just had to shoot his sheep or something and threw himself in the dam with a tractor tie around his neck. And
-
25:16
and John Fenton just went, well,
-
25:18
we've either gotta
-
25:20
get out of this business or we've gotta do something about it. So
-
25:24
he stitched up this
-
25:26
project with a researcher, Rod Bird, in in one of the government departments. So they they started working on how to plant Treefest.
-
25:34
And,
-
25:37
a lot of
-
25:38
the... You know, they started with pines
-
25:41
and anything really, you know, like John Taylor's approach where you just put anything in and see what happened.
-
25:46
And then they started doing a lot of trials with natives, and,
-
25:51
and then they got into farm forestry, and and John
-
25:54
got right into farm forestry.
-
25:56
And he ended up putting 30% of his property to,
-
25:59
to trees and increased his production.
-
26:03
Well, no. It wasn't just trees. That's why he he actually flooded old
-
26:07
swaps and... Re flooded old swaps and things.
-
26:11
So Rod Bird wrote all this sort of stuff up, and and he wrote up reports and manuals and sort of things like that. And,
-
26:19
David Curtis had got a lot of... Got a hold of a lot of his ideas and was, you know, working with,
-
26:26
with people up here to, you know, do that sort of stuff. Just forty years ago.
-
26:31
Yeah. But that is a long time ago, ain't it? Yeah. Well, when David picked it all up, it was sort of the early eighties, I think. And
-
26:39
he started doing the direct seeding and the,
-
26:42
you know, deep ripping and
-
26:45
David Carr
all that sort of thing. And we're about to come full circle. Yeah.
-
26:49
He'd come back there again. Do you know?
-
26:52
Yeah.
-
26:53
Was hope that, the knowledge is a little better now than it was then.
-
26:58
Steve Field
Yeah. That's what I think it
-
26:59
is. With direct seating anyway.
-
27:02
David Carr
You're... Oh, you're about to become the expert, River. Oh, well, I'm gonna need a lot of help before I know too much at all.
-
27:08
But it will be in... It it will definitely be an interesting
-
27:12
trip, I think. Yeah. I'm I'm looking forward to it.
-
27:16
Steve Field
Yeah.
-
27:17
Well, you got a big playground down Steve.
-
27:20
David Carr
Yeah. But once again, it comes right back... You know, you come full circle, don't you? If if I don't have people like yourself
-
27:28
to be out there, you know, seeking these these places out and getting access and
-
27:33
and, you know, I mean, it provides work for us as well, then then I can do little by myself.
-
27:38
Steve Field
Yeah. Yeah.
-
27:41
Yeah. I see part of my role is to
-
27:44
is sort of to motivate people and
-
27:47
get them thinking about why
-
27:49
why they want trees, and then
-
27:51
it's really good to be able to just go.
-
27:54
Have someone like you or, you know,
-
27:57
other seed collectors just to go,
-
27:59
right now, we need this much seed. We need
-
28:02
this planted and and know that it's actually gonna happen. Yeah.
-
28:06
David Carr
Well, it's a bit of a leap of faith for us as well. You know? I mean, we sort of... We we sort of dive in
-
28:11
and hope that we get support. Yeah. This is what I've said to some of the some of the other CMAs, you know. I mean, what what we what we are gonna need in the future
-
28:20
is actual business support from you guys. Yeah. Otherwise,
-
28:25
we'll just go the way of the dodo. You know,
-
28:28
it's...
-
28:28
Without without that, we can't survive. Yeah.
-
28:31
Steve Field
What do you mean business support? Just like drumming up customers. Yeah.
-
28:35
David Carr
Or the trials and, you know you know, it it is. It's it's about making sure that that they're out there letting know that... Letting people know that there is this service available.
-
28:46
Steve Field
Yeah.
-
28:47
David Carr
It's very hard for us to advertise.
-
28:49
We we have such a
-
28:52
a small niche in the community and it's a bit unusual, you know. Yeah.
-
28:58
Steve Field
Difficult for me to advertise on television. Yeah. It Carr me a fortune. Well, people aren't gonna just say an ad on telling you to go, oh, that's a good idea. Let's plant some trees.
-
29:09
Yeah. It start... It always starts out with,
-
29:12
you know, I I always foundry with doing all the extension stuff I've done that
-
29:17
you you just go out and you just form a relationship with people first. You might talk about their birds or their weeds
-
29:23
or what tree have I got in the paddock.
-
29:25
And next time you go out, they go... They got questions and they're saying, how do we plant
-
29:31
trees and
-
29:32
how would we get birds moving?
-
29:34
You know? The next time you go out, you you can start talking about a project. It's not like you...
-
29:40
You know? Most people, you don't just go, do you wanna plant some trees? And they go, yeah. Righto.
-
29:45
So it's all you gotta do, all that ground, all that
-
29:47
Yeah. Gostwyck, and then you,
-
29:50
David Carr
you can go, righto, well, Treefest Steve Field. How do how do you go with, like, with the,
-
29:56
the corporate
-
29:57
out
-
29:58
there?
-
29:59
I'm
-
30:01
not sure. You wouldn't actually be talking to the bloke that's making the decision.
-
30:05
Steve Field
No.
-
30:06
I think it's a mixed bag. We...
-
30:08
Depends on how much they... What do they call it? Corporate
-
30:12
social license or something. Yeah. You know, that if they feel like there's pressure on them, like the calcium
-
30:18
gas people and the miners at the moment,
-
30:21
they, you know, jump in through
-
30:23
all sorts of hoops just to make make the community like them.
-
30:27
So... But if you're a big anonymous corporate,
-
30:31
why would you invest well in
-
30:33
doing the right thing?
-
30:35
David Carr
You know? It is. It is. It's difficult for those folks, and it's not an easy job planting trees out there. But I think that we were about the third or fourth mob that went out there to plant trees. I know that we got ours Arding, but,
-
30:47
you know, just by manipulating
-
30:50
some of the... Some of our planting techniques and changing things around a bit. Yeah.
-
30:54
But I don't think we were the first.
-
30:56
Steve Field
No.
-
30:57
But,
-
30:59
pretty tough environment, like,
-
31:01
pretty easy to have disastrous
-
31:03
failures if you don't do it right.
-
31:06
David Carr
Yeah. It was.
-
31:08
It was always... There was a couple of areas that just continued to fail
-
31:13
on this.
-
31:14
And when I suggested some soil tests, though,
-
31:18
they they dismissed it out that
-
31:23
they didn't like the idea of a soil test being carried out.
-
31:26
Oh. Because of what they may find. Oh, okay.
-
31:31
So so, anyway, we decided not to plant those areas again for the third time. Yeah.
-
31:37
Steve Field
But you must River,
-
31:39
you you you got a pretty good,
-
31:42
you know, strike right there. So you you got a pretty good model that you... Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's
-
31:49
David Carr
it's... I mean, we've basically just taken off every other industry in it. Then we put in QAs. Yeah. Quality assurance. It's it's everything. Without that,
-
31:58
you, you just turn into, you know, debt and dove, you know, some sort of backyarders.
-
32:03
Yeah. And you have
-
32:05
no no standards,
-
32:07
that... That's why we...
-
32:09
That's the that's the vehicle that we've used
-
32:12
to,
-
32:13
maintain
-
32:15
maintain our work rate. Yeah.
-
32:19
Steve Field
So how does that affect your operations? What are you...
-
32:22
Does it... Do you just sort of codify what you're doing? Like, you say that we always do this and then we always do this. And... Well, pretty much. Pretty much. I mean, there's a little bit of license will get used if there's if there's something... An anomaly.
-
32:35
David Carr
Like, you know, we we
-
32:37
we would change
-
32:38
our work tactics if we were on a creek.
-
32:41
Yeah. And we don't wanna be going
-
32:43
whole as bowlers ripping stuff up if it's creak line. So obviously, it's horses for courses. But by and large,
-
32:50
we have we have taken the McDonald's model. Whereas, you know, it doesn't matter where in the world you are. If you buy a McDonald's hamburger, it tastes just the same.
-
32:59
And that's... And, you know, and that way they know their Carr. They know they know everything and so do we.
-
33:05
We know that when we turn up for planting that the preparation is gonna be just the way it's always been Really? Instead of walking into a job and finding out that we're gonna have to work three times as hard and for twice as long for the same amount of money. Yeah. Because that's a year. You can just can't afford to do that. Yep. So it is. And that rolls out into success too. Oh, for sure. Yeah. Like, the... Through survive. They do. Yeah. So we've gone... Yeah. We've sort of stepped it right to the to the top level.
-
33:33
And it also... At the end of the day, it works for the Rocky too because,
-
33:38
I mean, we can plant them easier. They get a higher strike rate,
-
33:41
but he's actually also able to look after it easier. He's not gonna be working nearly as hard. Yeah. So it's a it's a win win for everybody.
-
33:49
The cost's marginally higher.
-
33:51
But what we were finding years ago was that if we had a good strike,
-
33:57
the Rocky would actually cut back his program the next year and go, Oh, well.
-
34:01
It's... We we we won't do three rips now in that room. We'll just do one.
-
34:07
And then if they still had a success, they go,
-
34:10
I think if we just spry it and they can get them in. Yeah. You know, until eventually they Field. Yeah. And then they come back and say, your tree's all died.
-
34:20
Steve Field
You know what I mean?
-
34:21
Your tree is damaged.
-
34:23
David Carr
Exactly. So
-
34:24
we we just sort of foundry ourselves getting a bit set up like that. Yeah. And, you know, and we were working longer and harder for the same amount of money, you know. So... So there's still a lot of cockies that plant their own trees and then
-
34:36
Steve Field
we get so many theories about,
-
34:39
you know, you leave the grass, you don't spray the weeds, you do this, that, the other, and
-
34:43
that's fine if they wanna make the mistakes. But
-
34:46
I think it...
-
34:47
We we always try and push this idea, you know, weed control, weed control, weed control, ground preparation, quality seedlings, all that sort of stuff. And they go, yeah. Yeah. Right. We should all buggered it and then then it goes back to them for Well, the corporates are convinced that that's the right way to go. Yeah. Absolutely.
-
35:04
David Carr
They they don't mind.
-
35:05
It it... It's all about it's all about it must work. Yeah. It's not about the dollars.
-
35:11
It must work. Yeah. Because it costs you twice as much to do it. That's... That's right. Twice. That's right. And so it's it's it's the local cocky that... That's always been resistant to
-
35:21
to putting putting more money in. Yeah. You know? So So you're you're,
-
35:26
Steve Field
more,
-
35:27
authoritarian approach to
-
35:29
you do it or you don't plan. Exactly. Sort of foot pushes them into that doing the right thing. I provide all the gear for free.
-
35:36
David Carr
It's not like they even have to go and get anything and I'll deliver it. Yeah. You know, so I'm doing everything I can. Yeah.
-
35:44
But at the end of the day, I just know when, you know, when if they fail, they're my trees again.
-
35:50
Yeah. I mean, I've I've even had a failure after a year and a half, and they were my trees. Oh. They're two meters tall,
-
35:58
and they're my trees again because they've died. I don't I don't even know why they've died. You know, it could have been... Could be anything. Yeah.
-
36:05
But they're my trees again.
-
36:07
So I don't I don't I
-
36:09
don't understand that.
-
36:15
Steve Field
Okay. So we just had a short pause and,
-
36:18
we just decided we need to actually give a bit bit of background on where we both come from. So,
-
36:24
my involvement,
-
36:25
apart from my early
-
36:28
early
-
36:29
research as a a scout or dieback
-
36:32
in the nineteen seventies was,
-
36:35
getting involved with
-
36:37
the environment movement in the eighties and then
-
36:40
getting a job with,
-
36:41
Greening Australia under Dave Curtis and working with
-
36:45
Chris Nodoli,
-
36:47
for a long time. And then I
-
36:49
I left with the Canberra for
-
36:51
eight years, worked in the national office,
-
36:54
greening Australia,
-
36:55
and learned all about landscape Carr projects and really big scale projects. And then
-
37:00
I brought that back
-
37:01
to the region now with my
-
37:04
my business and then with, working with Landcare as well
-
37:08
and, pushing these big projects out out west, the big landscape scale project. So
-
37:14
so a lot of my stuff's been extension about
-
37:17
the research on academic stuff on revegetation
-
37:20
and then trying to talk people into doing it.
-
37:23
What about you?
-
37:25
David Carr
Well, I started off as a stockman station hand,
-
37:29
And in about ninety
-
37:32
one,
-
37:33
two... Let's say about ninety three or '4,
-
37:36
I started a small business called Fields Native Nursery,
-
37:41
which,
-
37:42
boy, basically were similar to the tree group in that we grew seedlings for,
-
37:48
revegetation works, and we also grew some,
-
37:51
household type plants as well.
-
37:53
And then we, within a short period of time, we realized that
-
37:57
we weren't really cut out to be a resale.
-
37:59
We weren't resale people.
-
38:01
We were all retail people.
-
38:03
So we got rid of that side of it and
-
38:07
got straight into,
-
38:09
wholesale and tree planting
-
38:12
and environmental works in general.
-
38:15
And that's that's progressed since since then right through till now where we have,
-
38:22
just secured,
-
38:24
a direct seating machine that we will now
-
38:28
we'll now, in conjunction with David and the CMAs,
-
38:32
try and get that out. So I I I think
-
38:36
what we... What David and I... Both our goals at the moment in long term would have to be
-
38:41
in gross
-
38:42
landscape change. That's...
-
38:45
We Carr sort of... We've been gearing that up for this. I think
-
38:48
this industry has been gearing up for this for the last fifteen years,
-
38:53
and we're probably still both maybe a bit ahead of our time.
-
38:56
So
-
38:57
in another twenty years, maybe
-
39:01
it'll be happening. Who knows? Yeah.
-
39:03
Steve Field
Well, when you consider it's been going for...
-
39:06
Well, for us, you know, nearly twenty years now anyway.
-
39:09
Another twenty years, it's gotta still be going. Probably the same people do it.
-
39:13
David Carr
Yeah. Well, we're all I won't be in twenty years.
-
39:17
Steve Field
I bet you will.
-
39:20
But
-
39:20
that's a lot of the next step. It's like going to another... It's like changing gears, isn't it? That's what I think of it now as we're trying to get,
-
39:27
you know Yeah. Doing it on a big scale. And for me, it's about,
-
39:31
you know, doing it on a scale we actually need to fix the landscape, you know, to allow birds to move through the landscape to
-
39:38
to,
-
39:39
keep the animals we've got, to keep the plant communities we've got. You've actually gotta put a lot of stuff back into the landscape.
-
39:46
David Carr
That's true. You've only got a... Driving out west, there's...
-
39:51
It's just been car parked. So much of it is just just been absolutely thoroughly cleared. And even what's growing out there might look a bit green, but it's just weeds. Yeah. Just weeds.
-
40:04
Steve Field
Carr hope it'll be moving faster. We'll just keep,
-
40:07
you know,
-
40:08
keep gradually moving,
-
40:10
get bigger, I think.
-
40:12
David Carr
Well, I hope so.
-
40:15
I I I think that we're
-
40:17
we're coming up to
-
40:18
a a a point
-
40:20
in in this industry or in this game
-
40:24
that it should start to take on a life of its own. It should start to become,
-
40:29
a mainstream business. I I think it should.
-
40:32
The worst thing that could happen is that it become a sort of a... An international business where you have American companies
-
40:38
Arding in and
-
40:40
and doing doing all of this and,
-
40:45
Steve Field
You might get that if we have a carbon rush.
-
40:48
David Carr
Mhmm. Get people covered in.
-
40:50
I have no idea. I don't even I don't even know how that works.
-
40:56
Steve Field
So... But we've got plenty to look forward to, don't we? Well, at least the good thing is that we got the skills to do it. Like, people like you and
-
41:02
few others, we can actually... If we generate the demand, we've got the... We could supply the service Steve. Yeah. For sure.