David Curtis and Chris Nadolny

Eucalypt dieback and what we've tried to do about it

Transcript

Machine draft Unreviewed Deepgram nova-2 output. Speakers are automatically assigned and may need checking against the recording.

  1. 0:01 Chris Nadolny

    One. Okay. My name's David Curtis, and I live in Wollongong.

  2. 0:06 David Curtis

    And my name's Chris Nadolny, and I live in Armadale.

  3. 0:12

    And today,

  4. 0:14

    it's,

  5. 0:15

    the 09/20/2012,

  6. 0:19

    and we're in Yooralla.

  7. 0:21

    And we're recording this as part of the Yooralla

  8. 0:24

    Story Project.

  9. 0:26

    And we're going to talk about

  10. 0:29

    New England dieback

  11. 0:32

    and what we tried to do about it.

  12. 0:35 Chris Nadolny

    So Chris, we, we both of us came from outside the area. So why don't we start with how we

  13. 0:42

    came came to Armidale? Do you wanna kick off? And

  14. 0:45 David Curtis

    I guess. Well, I I was

  15. 0:48

    in in Armadale. I originally

  16. 0:51

    came to do some,

  17. 0:54

    postgraduate

  18. 0:55

    study at the university,

  19. 0:58

    a diploma in science in agriculture, and

  20. 1:01

    and it kind of got me very interested in what was happening in the landscape.

  21. 1:07

    And after I finished that, I was actually

  22. 1:10

    not doing too much, working on a on a property,

  23. 1:14

    and everyone was starting to talk about dieback. And I and I thought I

  24. 1:20

    had some

  25. 1:21

    some knowledge because I'd,

  26. 1:23

    learnt

  27. 1:25

    about plant pathology,

  28. 1:28

    at university...

  29. 1:30

    At Monash University, and they were talking about

  30. 1:33

    dieback there that was related

  31. 1:35

    to cinnamon fungus.

  32. 1:37

    And I thought there might be some of the same thing going on. It turned out to be completely incorrect, but,

  33. 1:44

    but anyway, it got me interested in it. And I,

  34. 1:49

    joined

  35. 1:50

    the the botany department as a

  36. 1:53

    graduate student and

  37. 1:55

    went on. That's that's how...

  38. 1:57 Chris Nadolny

    And you started doing your master's on diabetic, didn't you? That's right. On all the causes. And you...

  39. 2:04

    Did you start with the cinnamon fungus stuff and then expand out? Is that how

  40. 2:10 David Curtis

    that worked? Yes. So I I I David. And

  41. 2:13

    and I suppose

  42. 2:15

    what I what I... I started out looking at that, but then I realized there were other things going on. And it was kind of interesting

  43. 2:24

    in those times.

  44. 2:28

    It was kind of like because we didn't really know for sure,

  45. 2:32

    everyone would come up with their own pet theory about Dieback.

  46. 2:38

    And there there were a 100 ideas

  47. 2:40

    floating around that it was

  48. 2:43

    caused

  49. 2:44

    by all all sorts of things, by by Super Phosphate and by,

  50. 2:51

    all sorts of diseases and by mistletoes

  51. 2:55

    and by by insects.

  52. 2:57

    And

  53. 2:58

    and there were all these

  54. 3:00

    root rot theories and...

  55. 3:03

    Yeah.

  56. 3:03

    All sorts of things. There were weird theories

  57. 3:06

    sort of about that it was caused by,

  58. 3:09

    pollution from the hunter Mhmm. And things like that. And

  59. 3:14 Chris Nadolny

    you explored just about every one of those, didn't you? You went up every rabbit hole and

  60. 3:18

    Yeah. Unpacked each of those. Yeah. That was kind of,

  61. 3:23 David Curtis

    in in retrospect, it was... That was a bit of,

  62. 3:28

    I I I suppose I had had to do do that.

  63. 3:32 Chris Nadolny

    So nobody else David,

  64. 3:34

    did they? I mean, well, other people were looking at bits of it, but you... Your masters

  65. 3:38

    kind

  66. 3:39

    of seemed to me at the time

  67. 3:41

    brought together every... All of those different ideas and explored

  68. 3:45

    their role.

  69. 3:47

    Yes.

  70. 3:48 David Curtis

    All that that was that was the I... Idea to to sort of try and work out what was going on Bundarra just...

  71. 3:56

    And so if someone came up with a theory, I'd I'd just

  72. 4:00

    just look at it,

  73. 4:02

    try and evaluate it,

  74. 4:04

    that that kind that kind of approach.

  75. 4:06

    But,

  76. 4:08

    I I suppose what what I what I found though was,

  77. 4:13

    when I... As I was looking at it,

  78. 4:16

    I I sort of started monitoring

  79. 4:18

    various trees and looking how their condition

  80. 4:22

    changed. And what I found was that, in general,

  81. 4:26

    the trees actually started improving.

  82. 4:29

    And and so I I suppose

  83. 4:32

    the upshot in my work was I was probably the first to notice that things were were actually getting better rather than worse. But it...

  84. 4:39

    Though that's kind of a little bit,

  85. 4:43

    yeah. I mean, in one way, they were getting better, but in another way, the trees that were really,

  86. 4:50

    really crook

  87. 4:51

    continued to die. So we actually... After the the trees,

  88. 4:57

    the healthy Treefest started together, that

  89. 4:59

    time, we actually probably lost

  90. 5:02 Chris Nadolny

    more trees than in the period before.

  91. 5:05

    So you you were doing your research

  92. 5:08

    after the peak of the dieback in a way. So you were coming in

  93. 5:12

    at the time that things were recovering. That's that's right. There was an ongoing mortality of some of the sicker trees that were dying. Yeah. That's that's right.

  94. 5:22

    And

  95. 5:23

    so I...

  96. 5:24

    So how come I came up here was

  97. 5:27

    because I met you when you were in the middle of that research,

  98. 5:31

    when you were at the Botanic Congress at Sydney Uni, when I... Where I was working. Yes. I recall that. And you had a poster

  99. 5:39

    there

  100. 5:40

    on the causes of dieback, which I remember talking to you about.

  101. 5:44

    And

  102. 5:45

    because I I came here as a student in in the early seventies, seventy three to River. So I sort of had an association with the New England, but then went to Sydney for five or six years.

  103. 5:57

    But

  104. 5:58

    kept visiting Armadale because I still had friends living here, and we'd come back quite regularly, you know, two or three times a year. So I'd sort of kept this link.

  105. 6:05

    And when when I married Fran and we had our first daughter, we were kind of... We're living in Sydney. We wanted to get out of Sydney. We were thinking about moving somewhere

  106. 6:15

    and,

  107. 6:16

    maybe the New England, maybe Orange, maybe Tasmania.

  108. 6:20

    And Fran was reminding me this morning that in 1980, so that was,

  109. 6:26

    we came up before we actually moved here, and I was sort of sussing it out thinking, oh, do I wanna come back? And

  110. 6:32

    apparently, I had this idea that I wanted to plant trees.

  111. 6:36

    Sort of forgotten Chris. She said, I

  112. 6:39

    thought of myself

  113. 6:41

    as actually become Johnny Appleseed of something, you know. So I had this grand plan for replacing the tree somehow.

  114. 6:47

    And,

  115. 6:49

    went to a... Went to Dieback. You know, there was that organization Growback That's right. The Dimerik Shire.

  116. 6:55

    And they they had they had this scheme for giving out plants. I think they're mostly pines and exotics, I think. There's quite a strong influence from forestry at the time of their their extension programs in that. Yeah. And apparently, I said to the guy, you know, what about natives? I want to plant native Treefest, and she said that he laughed.

  117. 7:13

    Laughed at me.

  118. 7:15

    So there... We had this kind of idea of moving

  119. 7:18

    back to New England because we wanted to be in the country. And I think meeting you at Sydney Uni, it probably

  120. 7:25

    crystalized that Bundarra somehow said I'd come up and work on dieback. Yeah.

  121. 7:30 David Curtis

    Actually, I I felt I felt that was

  122. 7:32

    what was needed at the time. I I was still continuing my work on the causes, but,

  123. 7:39

    yeah, it left the big question, what do we do afterwards?

  124. 7:42

    And and in particular, I think I was, oh, well, I was quite concerned about the attitude of,

  125. 7:51

    that the attitude was that

  126. 7:54

    the landscape had changed, the ecology

  127. 7:57

    had changed, and eucalypts could no longer grow on the New England.

  128. 8:02

    And so we had to just

  129. 8:04

    grow something else. And I and I didn't think that was

  130. 8:08

    right. And I felt

  131. 8:11

    that

  132. 8:12

    we shouldn't we shouldn't give up so quickly. Mhmm. And so,

  133. 8:17

    yeah, I think we needed

  134. 8:19 Chris Nadolny

    someone to do what you were proposing.

  135. 8:21

    Somebody unbelievably

  136. 8:23

    naive, probably.

  137. 8:25

    Yes. Then I had this kind of idea, well, some... Sooner or later, somebody David nut out the causes of dieback.

  138. 8:30

    And I thought, well, I don't wanna do that. Somebody else will do that. I'll try and nut out how to plant the trees. And

  139. 8:37

    so I

  140. 8:39

    somehow or other, I

  141. 8:41

    I got a tutor job at the uni,

  142. 8:44

    in the botany, a half time tutor position, and

  143. 8:47

    I had a dreadful degree. I had no... You know, I came out with a very poor science degree, and

  144. 8:52

    and they encouraged me to do some postgraduate work, and I started a master's prelim.

  145. 8:58

    And at the time, yes, I just wanted to establish trees, but then I came under the influence of Boire Wale, and he he gave it a scientific sort of frame. And I started looking at the regeneration of eucalypts, how they...

  146. 9:11

    The regeneration cycles

  147. 9:13

    and started some tree planting trials,

  148. 9:18

    some direct seeding trials. And you took me out in the field very early on in that process. And we went down to walk and we... I remember this very distinctly because I I made a very...

  149. 9:28

    What... While I still... That that plant collection that I took of that day where we collected all the main eucalypt species,

  150. 9:34

    mucilage, acacia Curtis, etcetera, all the main woodland species.

  151. 9:38

    And I made that little... I think that that collection is now at the tree group, I think,

  152. 9:44

    in that collection.

  153. 9:45

    And so you introduced me to each of the species and how how they've been affected by their work and explained

  154. 9:51

    the causes of dieback. And so for you... For me, the the person who has sort of shaped my understanding of dieback the most has probably been you because you've had that... Such a deep understanding of all the different causes.

  155. 10:04 David Curtis

    Yeah. Oh, well, that's,

  156. 10:06

    that that's good anyway. But I think,

  157. 10:10

    yeah, we were...

  158. 10:13

    Yeah. It was...

  159. 10:15

    I suppose the other thing that I that I sort of felt was,

  160. 10:19

    I mean, just in terms of regeneration,

  161. 10:21

    that

  162. 10:22

    where... Wherever,

  163. 10:26

    the system was intact,

  164. 10:29

    say, on the traveling stop routes and places like that,

  165. 10:33

    eucalypts were coming up by themselves. And, and the the juvenile

  166. 10:38

    eucalypts were

  167. 10:39

    were...

  168. 10:40

    They they were... Were sitting there

  169. 10:43

    as small

  170. 10:44

    sort of

  171. 10:46

    bush bush sized plants

  172. 10:49

    under the trees. And as soon as the trees died, they started growing and and taking over. And it was really

  173. 10:57

    in

  174. 10:58

    in the paddocks

  175. 11:00

    where where they've been,

  176. 11:04

    improving pastures

  177. 11:06

    and putting on super phosphate

  178. 11:09

    and

  179. 11:11

    and building up stock numbers where where the trees couldn't grow,

  180. 11:16

    where where we were losing them from the landscape. So

  181. 11:20

    so it was kind of like

  182. 11:22

    we had to do either either one thing, either manage

  183. 11:27

    less intensively so that the eucalypts could regenerate themselves.

  184. 11:31

    Or if we chose

  185. 11:33

    to intensify

  186. 11:35

    production,

  187. 11:36

    we needed

  188. 11:38

    to put the trees back, to plant them back.

  189. 11:41

    And so

  190. 11:43

    it's kind of like this I... Idea, which

  191. 11:46

    which I think...

  192. 11:47

    I'm sort of worried people are forgetting it now, that that

  193. 11:59

    the... Okay. After that short mobile phone interlude, I I forget what I was talking about. So we were talking about how we needed the double response between

  194. 12:09 Chris Nadolny

    conservation and encouragement of regeneration

  195. 12:11

    and the reestablishment.

  196. 12:12 David Curtis

    Yeah. And and people are forgetting that

  197. 12:16

    today.

  198. 12:17

    And,

  199. 12:19

    and for for years and years, for for two decades really after dieback,

  200. 12:25

    there's been encouragement

  201. 12:27

    for people to plant

  202. 12:29

    Treefest.

  203. 12:30

    But that seems to be diminishing now. There seems to be this notion

  204. 12:36

    that, well, do we have to plant trees and people are questioning

  205. 12:40

    things again? So,

  206. 12:43

    this is the catchment management authorities and... So putting the emphasis into just

  207. 12:48 Chris Nadolny

    protecting what's there Yeah. And not expanding.

  208. 12:52

    Yeah. Yeah. Whereas

  209. 12:54

    in our area, like, when we started, we were naive. We went straight into the most clear landscapes and and started there, started planting and connecting and...

  210. 13:03

    But... And and working out from from where we were. And and, you know, the farmers in the most clear country were the ones that wanted

  211. 13:10

    to put the trees dieback, weren't they? Yes.

  212. 13:13 David Curtis

    And and in retrospect, that was the right thing to do because

  213. 13:18

    because we went went into the most cleared areas or Mhmm. Or really you you did, I suppose. I

  214. 13:25

    I I sort of gave a bit of advice, but I didn't... Wasn't really,

  215. 13:30

    well, actually, I did take over planting. You David? You did. We'll get to that.

  216. 13:36

    But,

  217. 13:37

    but we we went into the most difficult areas

  218. 13:41

    just to prove that it could be done.

  219. 13:44 Chris Nadolny

    And because it could be done there, it could be done everywhere. Yeah. That's right. So, like, when I when I began my research, which started out as a little master's prelim two years, and then it expanded to

  220. 13:56

    a ten year master's program. So it's quite a long project part basically because I had to join part time work together over that ten years,

  221. 14:06

    which in hindsight turned out well because it meant for an ecological study that was a long time. I could follow the flowering cycles of the different eucalypt species and

  222. 14:15

    catch the seed fall, and and I was lucky enough to witness a couple of recruitment events of new seedlings, which is a rare rare event.

  223. 14:23

    But that research took that two pronged approach. We we went into areas and fenced and protected the regeneration and watched the regeneration

  224. 14:31

    occur or not occur depending

  225. 14:33

    on the situation. And we planted and direct seeded, so we worked out the technologies

  226. 14:38

    to plant.

  227. 14:39

    Mhmm. So I mean, by...

  228. 14:42

    I think

  229. 14:44

    for me, anyhow, one of the big key moments then that came for us was in 1983

  230. 14:49

    when we... I've been working on that research for a couple of years. You were coming to the end of your dieback research, and we we gave a joint presentation to Friends of the Earth

  231. 14:58

    on the causes of dieback and what what we could do about it. And that was '83, the year of the tree. Mhmm. And,

  232. 15:06

    I don't know. I can't quite remember the chronology of all Chris because the same things in 1983.

  233. 15:11

    There were other things occurring.

  234. 15:13

    I remember a brilliant seminar series at the TAFE that I heard Rob Davidson speak Curtis, Chris. You know, who who from CSIRO gave this electrifying, incredibly inspiring talk. I remember going home so inspired

  235. 15:26

    by his, you know, the use of habitat to create pest control.

  236. 15:31

    There was

  237. 15:32

    Richardson, Barb Baker, men of the trees, you know, doing his thing somewhere. You know, there was all that that's happening out there.

  238. 15:39

    And and so we spoke...

  239. 15:41

    You spoke about the causes of dieback. I spoke about, you know, some of the preliminary

  240. 15:47

    trials that... Or I was proposing. I don't think I'd even started them at that point or I was very early on, and floated the idea that we needed a tree planting group.

  241. 15:55

    And I think my idea was that we would have a 100 people each growing a thousand trees in their backyard,

  242. 16:01

    and then we would go out to farms and plant them.

  243. 16:04

    And we started in in my backyard with Fran when we had our first daughter, Ellen.

  244. 16:10

    And there's a photograph there of Ellie,

  245. 16:12

    pottering about with, no nappy and people potting up plants in in pots, you know, and milk cartons we used then. And we did things in sort of lots of a 100 or less, you know, such small numbers.

  246. 16:26

    And,

  247. 16:28

    embarked on a whole series of trials and so the... And then we formed the Armidale Tree Group out of that conversation. So Friends of the Earth, there was a guy there where... In Friends of the Earth, Tim Plater, who sort of took on took on the board, the whole thing, and began the organizational side. So we were

  248. 16:43

    able

  249. 16:43

    to... You with your knowledge of dieback and me... With my kind of

  250. 16:48

    insane

  251. 16:49

    urge to plant trees, we we somehow formed the tree group. And

  252. 16:53

    then over the eighties, I think... I was thinking about this this morning. The whole... The eighties period was where we we learned how to plant the trees. We learned how to seed by... We learn how to,

  253. 17:05

    protect the regeneration and and encourage it. So by the end of the decade, by the early... By 1990, we'd sort of cracked

  254. 17:12

    the growing of native Treefest. Whereas, you know, in the early eighties, people were very negative about growing them. They said, well, they couldn't grow. Bundarra

  255. 17:21

    only nursery stock came from Inverell Forestry, which, you know, is growing in those horrible forestry tubes in red clay, and they just, you know, they didn't go particularly well. Yeah.

  256. 17:31 David Curtis

    That's right. The other other thing that went wrong was they

  257. 17:35

    they usually took,

  258. 17:38

    collected the seed all over the place, usually in environments that weren't so cold, so the trees weren't adapted to the frosts.

  259. 17:46 Chris Nadolny

    So we had by... After a decade of that work, you know, the tree group was well established. It was... It brought down the cost of planting native trees

  260. 17:54

    with the speedlings. You had

  261. 17:57

    the the growth of technologies for tree planting right around the country, you know, with direct seeding machines and tree planting machines. We had people like the Taylors who were really getting stuck into

  262. 18:06

    big big, you know, planting projects themselves and designing tree planting machines and

  263. 18:12

    all that.

  264. 18:13

    So... And then the 1,000,000,000 trees

  265. 18:15

    program was launched in in, by the federal government along with the Landcare program in 1990.

  266. 18:21

    So Yeah. You had,

  267. 18:24

    and it had

  268. 18:26

    the the motto, encourage, enthuse,

  269. 18:29

    empower, didn't it? Empower,

  270. 18:31

    empower,

  271. 18:32

    educate, enthuse. And so there was money for

  272. 18:36

    encouragement

  273. 18:37

    and education and extension and

  274. 18:39

    and,

  275. 18:41

    enthusiasm... Empowerment. And so

  276. 18:43

    that fed in beautifully with the Landcare Movement, and we really then took off in the nineties with quite massive revegetation projects.

  277. 18:50 David Curtis

    Yeah. That's that's right. Newt became the regional organizer of Greening Australia,

  278. 18:56

    which gave you

  279. 18:59

    a a really important role there in coordinating all that.

  280. 19:03 Chris Nadolny

    Yeah. But before we finished the research, you know, there was also

  281. 19:08

    with that research that I'd started off as a small project. By the end of the eighties, we actually managed to get enough money for a full time position,

  282. 19:16

    which I I kicked off. And they were quite big revegetation

  283. 19:20

    trials, weren't they? And then you took over that in... When I moved to Greening Australia and kept that going for a couple more years. Yeah. That's that's right. I was always actually juggling that in a completely unrelated PhD

  284. 19:32 David Curtis

    project.

  285. 19:33

    But, On rainforests.

  286. 19:35

    Yeah. That's that's right. But,

  287. 19:38

    but that was

  288. 19:39

    that was interesting. I I I learned a lot by that, and it was it was kind of a a very interesting

  289. 19:45

    project because it didn't...

  290. 19:47

    It was kind of working with the the local farmers

  291. 19:51

    who,

  292. 19:54

    who who did a lot of the planting themselves and... Oh, well, actually, different ones did it in different ways. Sometimes

  293. 20:01

    I was doing the planting. Sometimes they were,

  294. 20:05

    and some of them were even propagating

  295. 20:07

    plants. And it was kind of

  296. 20:09

    interesting.

  297. 20:11

    I probably learned more from the the farmers because

  298. 20:14

    some

  299. 20:15

    some were doing it and they knew exactly what to do.

  300. 20:20

    The ground preparation was perfect. And it turned out that ground preparation was

  301. 20:26

    really important to

  302. 20:28

    to eliminate the weeds, to build up

  303. 20:31

    the the soil moisture,

  304. 20:32

    that sort of thing. And,

  305. 20:35

    and there were a few people like...

  306. 20:37

    That's where I first met Steve Field who's become a,

  307. 20:43

    a major

  308. 20:44

    planting contractor and he... Right around the state. Yeah. He was working,

  309. 20:50

    with

  310. 20:51

    Gordon

  311. 20:52

    Williams.

  312. 20:53

    They were very enthusiastic

  313. 20:57

    tree

  314. 20:58

    tree planters.

  315. 21:00

    And,

  316. 21:01

    and it was kind of interesting. They they had

  317. 21:04

    90%

  318. 21:06

    survival, whereas everyone else was having sort of 50, 60%.

  319. 21:10

    And and I was sort of... We're able to work out why they were succeeding

  320. 21:14

    and why other people were failing. So

  321. 21:17

    we're able to we

  322. 21:19

    were able to,

  323. 21:23

    to to sort of improve how we were doing it

  324. 21:27

    and and just sort of little things. I remember that the sort of notion we we sort of observed that

  325. 21:34

    if it rained on the day we planted, we had a better

  326. 21:37

    success. So, I mean, it sounds really silly now, but just

  327. 21:42

    the the notion that you had to really water the Mhmm.

  328. 21:47

    The trees

  329. 21:48

    in well when you planted them,

  330. 21:51

    sort of, and we bought bought a tanker and then suddenly our success rate went up. Yeah. And... But it was mostly the the little things, growing the the seedlings,

  331. 22:01

    just details about how they...

  332. 22:03

    How to grow them better, that kind of thing. Mhmm. And,

  333. 22:07 Chris Nadolny

    was it was interesting anyway. I think what you're saying there about the relationship between you as a researcher and the landholder,

  334. 22:14

    like... And the innovative ones in particular

  335. 22:17

    Yeah.

  336. 22:18

    That relationship was really

  337. 22:20

    really important

  338. 22:21

    dynamic. And it was the same with me when I started in the early eighties, the same thing that we... You had...

  339. 22:28

    Some landholders were very innovative and kind of,

  340. 22:32

    did you as a

  341. 22:33

    researcher... You were coming up with some ideas, but they were also... They were... In some cases, you were just going off the ideas that were coming from the individual landholder. Oh, I did. But... And I think, actually, that relationship between researchers and and

  342. 22:46

    people on the land has continued right to now. I mean, when you look at Nick Reid's research, ecological research, he's still continuing that relationship, isn't he, between landholders and the researchers? It's active research. It's active, whatever you call it, action research.

  343. 23:00

    It's been really dynamic relationship. And and also then the the

  344. 23:05

    nursery industry itself or the revegetation industry feeding into that. So like with Steve Field you described who then went off and established his own... He started with Gordon,

  345. 23:14

    then he went off and established his own tree planting,

  346. 23:18

    nursery and his tree planting business. The same with the Armadale Tree Group. We're always really involved.

  347. 23:23

    Well, it came out of, you know, we joined the... In terms of my research, they planted the trees that I was monitoring and, you know, the big Melpa stand planting that was a huge breakthrough for native veg that, you know, I was monitoring that from the uni, but the tree group was organizing the planting.

  348. 23:41

    That's that's been pretty crucial. And then people like Mike O'Keefe who were developing

  349. 23:46

    the propagation methods, which,

  350. 23:50 David Curtis

    yeah. Yeah. Well, that that was a really... A real step up Yeah. When when he took over as manager of the

  351. 23:58

    the tree group nursery. Yeah. And it's worth

  352. 24:01 Chris Nadolny

    reflecting on how

  353. 24:03

    some of those institutions have built, isn't it? You know, like Mhmm. With the tree group, which began in our backyard by the end of the

  354. 24:11

    nineties...

  355. 24:12

    By the end of the eighties was just getting Arding, and Mike took over around about the time I went to Greening Australia. And

  356. 24:19

    by the end of the nineties, I mean, it was producing

  357. 24:22

    100,000 plants a year. Fields Nursery was as well. Some of the other nurseries were. I think I did a... An estimation

  358. 24:30

    that by the 2000,

  359. 24:32

    the nursery industry up here was pumping out about 700,000

  360. 24:35

    tubes a year. Yeah. And, it's probably gone up

  361. 24:38

    further from there. I mean, Taylor's brought in the HEICO

  362. 24:42

    planting technology that really, you know, took off and made planting a lot easier. And,

  363. 24:48

    that was pretty crucial as well.

  364. 24:50

    But at the same time, all that revenge was going on, there's also been this other strand of conserving areas of bushland, hasn't there? So Yes. You know, I think over the nineties,

  365. 25:00

    through 1,000,000,000 trees funding and save the bush funding and

  366. 25:05

    whatever all the, you know, the National Heritage Trust and

  367. 25:08

    Landcare and all the other programs caring for our country that have come come about since then. I think I've estimated it's over 12 and a half thousand hectares of bushland that was conserved by River that

  368. 25:19

    decade of the nineties, the decade of Landcare. But then since then,

  369. 25:23

    you know, probably twice that amount has has gone

  370. 25:27

    and protected. So you've had both

  371. 25:29 David Curtis

    kind of things happening, haven't you? That... That's right. And and I suppose

  372. 25:34

    a lot a lot of this came from

  373. 25:37

    Rob Davidson's

  374. 25:38

    idea that...

  375. 25:39

    And and it's kind of

  376. 25:41

    funny just sort of picking out a a percent so that people have a target, but he says 10%

  377. 25:48

    of farms should

  378. 25:50

    be managed

  379. 25:51

    for for nature conservation.

  380. 25:54

    Not necessarily never grazed, but but managed so that the bush is promoted.

  381. 26:00

    And

  382. 26:02

    and and I think that's been

  383. 26:04

    a a really pivotable Arding.

  384. 26:06

    And and kind of like... I I think a lot of farmers also

  385. 26:11

    realized

  386. 26:13

    that dieback was

  387. 26:16

    a symptom

  388. 26:17

    of

  389. 26:18

    a breakdown in the balance of nature. Mhmm. And

  390. 26:22

    and just...

  391. 26:24

    And the notion

  392. 26:26

    that...

  393. 26:27

    Well, what caused dieback was chiefly

  394. 26:31

    insects, but there are insects

  395. 26:33

    that are native

  396. 26:35

    to to the tablelands.

  397. 26:38

    And,

  398. 26:39

    and they occur there

  399. 26:41

    every...

  400. 26:42

    Have always occurred there. So

  401. 26:44

    so why

  402. 26:46

    did

  403. 26:47

    did the populations

  404. 26:48

    break out and that sort of thing? And it was partly the the lack of

  405. 26:53

    the lack of things like

  406. 26:56

    flowering plants

  407. 26:57

    to to feed the the parasites that feed on the insects, and it was partly,

  408. 27:05

    the added nutrients that made the insect populations

  409. 27:08

    build up faster

  410. 27:10

    than than they would have naturally.

  411. 27:12

    And

  412. 27:14

    and so...

  413. 27:15

    And partly weather. And partly weather. Yes. And and that was... And that's kind of an interesting Yes. Thing because

  414. 27:23

    it was really the the wet period in the mid seventies

  415. 27:27

    that caused

  416. 27:29

    the big outbreaks.

  417. 27:31

    Yeah. And,

  418. 27:32

    yeah, the mid seventies. And we we really haven't had

  419. 27:36

    anything like that

  420. 27:38

    till the recent

  421. 27:40

    couple couple years. And and that's why,

  422. 27:44

    I've been telling you I'm concerned again that we... We've we've kind of gone down,

  423. 27:51

    a pathway where

  424. 27:53

    we... We're sort of forgetting

  425. 27:56

    the old lessons. We're forgetting that we have to keep that balance with nature,

  426. 28:01

    and

  427. 28:02

    people have started

  428. 28:04

    trying to get more out of their pastures, putting on more fertilizer again.

  429. 28:09

    They've tried,

  430. 28:11

    they've started

  431. 28:12

    grazing

  432. 28:13

    everywhere heavily,

  433. 28:14

    forgetting about the bush and The The regeneration.

  434. 28:17

    And and Bundarra scrubbing bush

  435. 28:20

    and and, yeah, forgetting

  436. 28:22

    that,

  437. 28:23

    yeah, they have to plant trees

  438. 28:26

    and and all all those

  439. 28:28 Chris Nadolny

    lessons. So I'm so I'm... So a lot of the factors are kind of leading the direct in the first place. They're sort of repeating now, you think? Yes. And there could be another outbreak. Yes. So the question is, was enough dieback?

  440. 28:42

    Has has enough been done to

  441. 28:44

    ensure that those ecosystems are resilient enough? You know,

  442. 28:48

    we've been talking about this over the last couple of days in in preparation for this talk, haven't we? You know, I was thinking, well, yeah, there's there's there's been the work on the ground and the conservation

  443. 28:58

    areas, and there's been this huge building... Build up of capacity in the community through the research and through the extension programs from,

  444. 29:07

    you know, from forestry in the early days and then Greening Australia, the tree group Landcare.

  445. 29:11

    There's all that institution building that's occurred with

  446. 29:15

    the Landcare networks and the tree group Greening Australia,

  447. 29:20

    CMAs, catchment management authorities, and so on. There's been all these pioneering people that we've some of whom we've referred to today.

  448. 29:27

    Landholders, people in the community, scientists

  449. 29:30

    has been

  450. 29:31

    the funding that's come in. There's been the build up of the River industry.

  451. 29:35

    And what I think has been really crucial also is is the culture of Landcare that's emerged as well, you know, whether it's

  452. 29:41

    particular artists that have been responded to the landscape and created empathy for the landscape or painted about dieback like Angus Nivison's

  453. 29:51

    done. There's been, you know, community arts events like Nova Anglicur, which celebrated all the land care.

  454. 29:58

    There's been big big events, small events, the Littlefield Days, the the big events like Treefest

  455. 30:05

    and and Novo Anka Ka and more recently God's Drawing Board, which is that composition which celebrated

  456. 30:10

    the Landcare efforts and reversing dieback and celebrating the the work of people like Mike O'Keefe and Mark Sandstrom, who are great pioneers planters.

  457. 30:20

    So there's there's all those strands in building our capacity. Did I say the River industry too? They're all that. Mhmm. Has it been enough? And

  458. 30:29

    why, you know, this is kind of an interesting question.

  459. 30:31 David Curtis

    Yeah. Well, it's kind of interesting because

  460. 30:34

    the revegetation

  461. 30:36

    industry

  462. 30:37

    is,

  463. 30:39

    not quite

  464. 30:41

    what it what it was ten years ago. It's actually probably

  465. 30:45

    declined in a in a lot of ways.

  466. 30:48

    I mean,

  467. 30:49 Chris Nadolny

    actually, it's... Does that happen really though? Because I was talking to Dave about Chris, Dave Carr yesterday about Chris, and he's saying Steve Sweeney is now putting out a 100,000 a year, and the trade group would still be...

  468. 31:00 David Curtis

    Has the capacity

  469. 31:02

    dropped?

  470. 31:03

    Yeah. Well,

  471. 31:04

    actually, I I don't know. It's kinda like...

  472. 31:07

    It's it's actually difficult to say because there's sort of wins and losses.

  473. 31:13

    And I suppose

  474. 31:15

    one win is

  475. 31:17

    that

  476. 31:18

    the technology's improved,

  477. 31:20

    and it's improved through

  478. 31:23

    through things like,

  479. 31:26

    well,

  480. 31:28

    better better propagation

  481. 31:29

    methods, that sort of thing.

  482. 31:31

    Though

  483. 31:32

    though in some respects,

  484. 31:36

    we've probably forgotten

  485. 31:38

    more in the last ten years about direct seeding than we've we've gained. We've sort of forgotten things because,

  486. 31:44

    I mean, Mike O'Keefe's tragic death and

  487. 31:48

    and and things like that. People

  488. 31:51

    people who've,

  489. 31:52

    yeah, died or retired

  490. 31:54 Chris Nadolny

    or... Well, they don't tell me that Steve Fields just bought a direct seater.

  491. 31:58

    Yeah. Well... And Broad River Guider has two or Landcare or someone has Landcare. I think someone's bought another. So maybe that... Anyway. Yeah. Well, I well, I think,

  492. 32:08 David Curtis

    I think there is

  493. 32:10

    scope

  494. 32:10

    for things improving too.

  495. 32:13

    But,

  496. 32:14

    I think,

  497. 32:16

    just in terms of our our efforts to revegetate,

  498. 32:21

    if you sort of think about it... Arding. I was

  499. 32:24

    suggesting this before that the actual tree cover

  500. 32:27

    over the whole of the tablelands has probably probably been declining

  501. 32:32

    even even with

  502. 32:34

    the the efforts to

  503. 32:38

    to replant

  504. 32:39

    lots of Treefest. And it's because

  505. 32:41

    the

  506. 32:43

    the belts of trees that are planted are usually very dense belts, so they're very good for windbreaks. And they're important.

  507. 32:50

    Mhmm. But they don't cover the landscape. But then

  508. 32:54

    but then there are things

  509. 32:56

    like,

  510. 32:57

    Shane Andrews been

  511. 32:59

    been trialing this engineered woodlands.

  512. 33:02

    Mhmm. This this sort of notion,

  513. 33:04

    and and and actually, a few years ago, I I was quite enthusiastic

  514. 33:09

    about

  515. 33:10

    the the notion of planting for carbon because

  516. 33:13

    you have a win win situation.

  517. 33:15 Chris Nadolny

    And that could well take off with new initiatives from the federal government on the carbon programs. Yeah. And the engineered woodlands idea is a really interesting idea that I think

  518. 33:27

    builds in agroforestry

  519. 33:28

    along with habitat,

  520. 33:29

    along with shelter, across whole landscapes. It's a very interesting idea.

  521. 33:34 David Curtis

    Well well, it it it sort of brings in part of our recent research has shown that

  522. 33:41

    that actually...

  523. 33:42

    Or agriculture

  524. 33:44

    production for livestock

  525. 33:46

    is actually higher

  526. 33:48

    in a landscape which

  527. 33:50

    is partially treed.

  528. 33:52

    And where where you've got a...

  529. 33:55

    If you have a... Particularly if there's native pastures, if you have a a woodland setting,

  530. 34:02

    the

  531. 34:02

    the grasses actually grow a lot better.

  532. 34:07

    Trees

  533. 34:08

    make the soil more nutritious,

  534. 34:11

    and they moderate the climate. So you don't have these severe frosts.

  535. 34:16

    It means that

  536. 34:18

    pasture can continue to grow through winter where... And the big problem

  537. 34:23

    in grazing on the tablelands

  538. 34:25

    is that there's a

  539. 34:28

    a,

  540. 34:30

    lack of growth in winter

  541. 34:32

    and early Arding, and that's where...

  542. 34:36

    When stock production is most limited, and and trees help to moderate that. So

  543. 34:42

    so if... So I think, you know, there's there's a win win there.

  544. 34:47 Chris Nadolny

    Yeah. That's right. So the balance... Like, the the the question of whether we've done enough, I think...

  545. 34:54

    Well, time will tell. I mean, I... Because I'm an infrequent... I don't live here now, so I come back

  546. 34:59

    every six months, every year. Mhmm.

  547. 35:02

    I see my friends getting older, which is really

  548. 35:06

    hard.

  549. 35:07

    But also, the trees we planted are getting older as well,

  550. 35:10

    and, you know, they will outlive us. And I I think increasingly now about succession, about continuance, about the long term resilience. And and seemingly,

  551. 35:22

    I keep getting roped into these kinds of story kind of things where people wanna know the story of dieback.

  552. 35:27

    Keep getting interviewed for these kinds of things. And for the Treefest, I've been asked to reflect on on it as well.

  553. 35:33

    And

  554. 35:34

    to me,

  555. 35:35

    you know, like, the resilience of the ecosystems,

  556. 35:38

    I suspect

  557. 35:39

    we haven't done enough, you know, to make them resilient

  558. 35:42

    for another way. But there probably will be

  559. 35:45

    areas that,

  560. 35:47

    continue to succumb, as you described. You know, the trees

  561. 35:51

    are out in the paddocks and those sorts of things. And Mhmm. The pattern of vegetation in the... Or pattern of trees in Landcare will change over time as

  562. 36:00

    we respond and we reengineer the landscapes

  563. 36:03

    over time. But,

  564. 36:05

    there will probably be scope to do more work for quite a long time yet. But I I place a lot of story in the capacity that's been built in the Landcare, in in the community, you know, all

  565. 36:16

    those strands coming from the research and from the extension and the institutions that we've built built up, the people, the pioneers

  566. 36:23

    who are inspired.

  567. 36:26

    And inevitably,

  568. 36:27

    yes, the farms will change hands. I know we're seeing that now with some of the... Those early people who we worked with, the Williams and Taylors, and some of those are now handing their properties over to their children or they're being sold.

  569. 36:38

    And, the institutions are changing, like Greening Australia came and went. Its roles were picked up by the tree group and by Landcare and,

  570. 36:47

    the CMAs, catchment management authorities and so on. So that there's a certain amount of resilience in that community system, that social system

  571. 36:55

    for succession.

  572. 36:57

    And

  573. 36:58

    to me, the the crucial thing is maintaining a Landcare culture, a culture of land care where we... That that if the idea

  574. 37:06

    for trees in the landscape

  575. 37:08

    is maintained,

  576. 37:09

    then

  577. 37:11

    a a lot of the other stuff will follow.

  578. 37:14 David Curtis

    Yeah.

  579. 37:15

    Yeah. I'd I'd...

  580. 37:16

    I'm I'm

  581. 37:18

    a little bit hazy on where the future where... Is taking us. So I think,

  582. 37:24

    there... There's one thing I remember you

  583. 37:27

    you said or actually wrote in

  584. 37:29

    one of our early papers, and

  585. 37:32

    that was...

  586. 37:33

    You were talking about how,

  587. 37:37

    as we

  588. 37:38

    we change,

  589. 37:40

    people are becoming more and...

  590. 37:42

    Or as we evolve in society, people are coming more and more remote from the environment and they're they're going to their computer screens and things like that. And very often,

  591. 37:54

    it's it's easy to be out of step

  592. 37:57

    with what's going on in nature if you are Mhmm. If you do lose those

  593. 38:02

    connections.

  594. 38:03

    But it's...

  595. 38:05

    I mean, but, but it's not necessarily,

  596. 38:08

    I mean, technology can be a good thing. Technology can

  597. 38:12

    create connections and enhance understanding. So,

  598. 38:17

    yeah, I I I really don't know. So that kind of experience of nature

  599. 38:21 Chris Nadolny

    where, you know, the return to TreeFest or the children of TreeFest event that's taken place tomorrow or this week

  600. 38:27

    is a really great...

  601. 38:29

    It might be a good place to end, you know, the conversation in a way because you had

  602. 38:33

    the reflection of what occurred in Treefest ninety two where 6,000 people came to that farm

  603. 38:39

    and

  604. 38:40

    talked about trees on farms, and it was River a 100 exhibits. You know, like, it was an amazing event. All the who's who from trees on farms around the country came to it.

  605. 38:48

    And that property has now changed hands to the children, Catherine and Michael. They're

  606. 38:53

    they're reflecting on what led to the first Treefest, and they're looking forward to the future in terms of what that means for the landscape and the resilience of the social and the and the ecological systems.

  607. 39:05

    And, you know, I place great story in those kinds of cultural events in passing on because the children, you know, will be going to that. The the different generations of farmers will be going to it. The new generations of property owners and,

  608. 39:17

    and people involved in community organizations like Landcare

  609. 39:20

    and Greening... Not Greening Australia, but the tree group and so on,

  610. 39:25

    will be there. And so it's a kind of looking back, learning from those lessons from the past, but also thinking ahead

  611. 39:31

    of sort of celebrating and anticipating the future and continuing

  612. 39:34

    that kind of culture through the through the region. I think that's gonna be the the crucial thing to maintain.

  613. 39:41 David Curtis

    Yeah. Oh, look. I'm I'm looking forward to that. I've

  614. 39:44

    I've,

  615. 39:45

    been working in other other

  616. 39:47

    areas, and I've sort of

  617. 39:49

    lost contact with a a few of the,

  618. 39:52

    oh, well, quite

  619. 39:54

    most of the farmers that I used to work with and maybe

  620. 39:58

    be able to sort of catch up with a few people

  621. 40:02

    and see what what happens and where they've been where they've been going. That'd be interesting.

Back to top