Transcript
Machine draft Unreviewed Deepgram nova-2 output. Speakers are automatically assigned and may need checking against the recording.
-
0:01
Barry McDonald
My name is Hamish Sewell, and I'm talking with Barry McDonald.
-
0:07
Today's date is the nineteenth, and we're in Yooralla.
-
0:10
And we're recording
-
0:12
as part of the Yooralla Barry Project.
-
0:15
And we're gonna talk today about
-
0:17
Barry's work involved in collecting
-
0:21
music, folk music around the New England area.
-
0:27
Speaker 2
Where do you wanna start, Barry? Well, I guess the first thing I'd like to
-
0:31
start with
-
0:32
is
-
0:33
to say that I've gone right off
-
0:36
the descriptive word collecting
-
0:38
in recent years.
-
0:44
Although when I was involved in
-
0:46
the recording project,
-
0:48
I guess
-
0:50
the whole idea of collecting
-
0:52
informed
-
0:53
the work I was Arding, but when I look back at it now,
-
0:58
the the parts of my work that I'm ashamed of,
-
1:02
are those
-
1:04
aspects that,
-
1:06
were really aligned most closely with the
-
1:09
the attitude of collecting
-
1:11
Barry McDonald
from people. So does the idea of collecting have this kind of almost anthropological
-
1:16
Speaker 2
sort of connotation to it? It has. It... It's, you know, the outsider coming in,
-
1:22
and
-
1:23
not really,
-
1:25
entering into relationship with the people from whom they're collecting,
-
1:30
taking their material,
-
1:32
for
-
1:33
whatever purpose,
-
1:35
that really didn't
-
1:37
involve
-
1:38
that the later use of that material didn't involve the people
-
1:42
who actually gave it
-
1:43
willingly
-
1:44
and probably not as knowingly
-
1:47
as,
-
1:48
you know, one would like now,
-
1:53
but generously. And I think it's that generosity and and naivety not to to use that word pejoratively,
-
2:01
that makes me feel
-
2:03
or makes me react so greatly now to to the whole idea of collecting.
-
2:08
Barry McDonald
But there was an interest there to start with, wasn't there?
-
2:12
My interest? Yeah. Yeah. Where did that begin?
-
2:16
Speaker 2
Okay. Well, when I moved up to the, Tablelands, I
-
2:20
found myself
-
2:21
living in a small hut,
-
2:25
next to
-
2:26
an old man
-
2:27
who who lived in the adjacent hut,
-
2:31
in an area called Tillbuster just north of Armidale.
-
2:34
And he was an accordion player and a bush poet and a singer,
-
2:38
and he
-
2:39
introduced me to the whole idea of this
-
2:42
this bush culture.
-
2:44
Barry McDonald
Were you playing music at that stage? Yeah. I was. What were you playing? I was playing mainly Irish folk music
-
2:50
Speaker 2
with an interest in Australian music, but a side interest.
-
2:54
I was playing mandolin.
-
2:56
Barry McDonald
Alright.
-
2:57
Speaker 2
And this bloke played the accordion, and he was very keen to share
-
3:01
what,
-
3:02
what he knew, what he had.
-
3:04
Unfortunately, he did not live very long after,
-
3:08
I knew him.
-
3:10
But he he gave me a notebook that he kept,
-
3:14
for decades,
-
3:16
where he copied down the words of songs
-
3:18
and rhymes and recitations that he'd held in the bush
-
3:21
throughout his life.
-
3:23
So, I never... I didn't record him.
-
3:26
After I met him, I met a,
-
3:30
a man by the name of Chris Sullivan, who also
-
3:34
came to live in the New England,
-
3:36
and Chris was very interested in a much more,
-
3:41
informed way
-
3:43
about bush culture
-
3:44
and the need to,
-
3:48
document,
-
3:50
what was disappearing.
-
3:52
And I think it was Chris's
-
3:55
inspiration
-
3:56
that took me further.
-
3:58
But the whole
-
4:00
the whole thing was was,
-
4:05
influenced very much by the idea that there was
-
4:08
a certain amount of material
-
4:10
out there
-
4:11
to be recorded,
-
4:13
and that it needed to be done quickly.
-
4:18
And in a sense, it it was like collecting anything or like storing up anything
-
4:23
or hoarding anything. It was, you know, let's see how much we can get today, and I wonder what pockets of treasure lie here, there, or wherever.
-
4:32
Let's go and explore and then, you know,
-
4:35
gather the treasures in and, you know, hoard them Bundarra ourselves, basically. Well, I'm not talking... I don't wanna talk about that's Chris's attitude. That's... Was my attitude.
-
4:43
But it wasn't
-
4:45
I wasn't Robinson Crusoe, you know. That's how things were done
-
4:50
pretty much, I think. When are we talking?
-
4:53
1979
-
4:54
Barry McDonald
was the beginning. Wow. 1979. Yeah. Wow. So we're talking a long time ago. Yeah. So you'd have been doing this for a good thirty years now. I did it for twenty years,
-
5:05
Speaker 2
and then I moved from New England to Central Australia.
-
5:08
Barry McDonald
Yeah. That was the end of my... Life. And you you were no longer collecting
-
5:13
the stories from the the music from the bush culture. You were no longer involved in recording stuff like that. No. Right. Well, this... That bush culture doesn't exist in the Northern Territory.
-
5:23
No. Oh, you... Barry. You went to Victoria and the Northern Territory. Sorry. I went to Central Australia. Yeah. Yeah.
-
5:30
Speaker 2
It's quite unique around here. And it was? No.
-
5:34
No. It's not unique to New England. It's... It... It's new.
-
5:37
What's new unique about the Northern Territory is that it doesn't exist
-
5:42
there.
-
5:43
So
-
5:44
Barry McDonald
if you know what I mean. So... I'm a bit confused. So we've got Victoria, we've got New England. I don't know where Victoria came in. So so from here you moved to the Northern Territory. That's it. Right? And that that bush culture Yeah. That music that's... That that you were... That you had been involved in recording Yeah. Doesn't doesn't exist up there. No. Do you wonder why that's the case?
-
6:03
Speaker 2
Lots of reasons.
-
6:04
One of them would be climate, I imagine.
-
6:06
Musical instruments wouldn't
-
6:09
wouldn't last very long up there.
-
6:12
Another one is the pattern of settlement, white settlement.
-
6:18
I have... There are a couple of instances of, you know, there are records of
-
6:24
people having played accordions or concertinas or something like that out there, but they're very,
-
6:29
very few.
-
6:30
Barry McDonald
Because this is one of the earlier settled places in Australia, isn't it?
-
6:34
Speaker 2
I guess so. Though I think that,
-
6:37
the culture that... The musical culture that existed here was... Existed all over Australia
-
6:42
everywhere except for the Northern Territory. Which was
-
6:45
Barry McDonald
pastoral. It had a high sort of, you know, there was a there was a fair percentage of kind of,
-
6:50
Anglo Celtic
-
6:51
stuff, the traditional Anglo Celtic stuff. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
-
6:54
Speaker 2
Definitely.
-
6:55
Barry McDonald
And and that that had those kind of folk,
-
6:58
folk roots. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So it was a transplant of traditional, I suppose. Yeah. And you you were plugged into that a bit with your own music at that stage, I suppose, weren't you? Yep. With playing the Landcare. Yep. Were you playing tunes?
-
7:11
Yep. Sort of the Irish, traditional Irish tunes. Yep. Yep. And you've got Irish anter, you've got Irish I have. A background in you too. Yep. And and that's quite important to you, isn't it? It is. Yeah.
-
7:22
Speaker 2
Yes. It's important. I mean, we were... I was I was read
-
7:26
with a a,
-
7:28
consciousness of my Irish background, but I didn't know how extensive it was until very recently. But it's very extensive, so
-
7:35
15 of my 16 great great grandparents were born and reared in Ireland.
-
7:40
And the last ones
-
7:42
to migrate to Australia migrated in 1864,
-
7:45
so
-
7:46
it was a long time ago.
-
7:49
But notwithstanding
-
7:50
the
-
7:50
the amount of time that my family line
-
7:54
has endured in Australia or existed in Australia,
-
7:57
it's still intensely... There's hardly anything but Irish ancestry in my background,
-
8:02
Yeah.
-
8:04
Which is explained by the enclave
-
8:06
mentality of... Or the experience of the Irish who
-
8:10
stayed together when they came here and married into each other and whatever, so... And kept on marrying into each other.
-
8:17
So I guess there was an attraction to Irish music,
-
8:20
and I I I guess we took the attitude, or I took the attitude,
-
8:26
not uninfluenced by other people,
-
8:30
that
-
8:31
informed,
-
8:32
or the approach that informed
-
8:35
the,
-
8:36
you know, talk about,
-
8:38
and collecting of Irish music in Ireland, so that that anthropological approach
-
8:44
in Ireland informed my approach to,
-
8:47
you know, doing stuff in Australia.
-
8:51
So I had read,
-
8:53
you know, works of, folkloric works and,
-
8:57
you know, seen,
-
8:59
musical...
-
9:00
Books about music... Folk music from Ireland, etcetera. So...
-
9:05
Barry McDonald
And was it the fact that the Irish had been involved in a sort of continual
-
9:09
struggle for their own culture, for their language, for their identity that partly attracted you to that as well?
-
9:17
Speaker 2
I don't think so. I don't think I was ever that conscious. It was...
-
9:21
No. That wasn't
-
9:24
part of the story that was handed down to me.
-
9:28
I don't think River was, no, because,
-
9:30
you know,
-
9:33
the the Irish enclave in which I grew up,
-
9:38
I don't think ever saw itself as oppressed.
-
9:41
It was
-
9:43
it was cracking Barry.
-
9:45
It was declaring itself,
-
9:48
and I don't think there was any room for a sob story, you know. So that I was,
-
9:53
you know, apart from, you know, going to church weekly,
-
9:57
to mass weekly, I was educated by Christian brothers right through my schooling.
-
10:01
The Christian brothers were an Irish order. Everything was,
-
10:06
you know, oriented towards Ireland, I suppose, now that I see it. But I I grew up in the milieu and it was like a fish in water, you know, I didn't... I wasn't aware of the water. Yeah. Yeah. Mhmm. What was it like growing up in an Irish,
-
10:19
Barry McDonald
when the the Christian Bundarra system? Terrible.
-
10:22
Speaker 2
Yeah. Where was it? Oppressive. First was Saint Leo's College in Waitara in Sydney,
-
10:28
and then I went to Christian Brothers College Waverley.
-
10:31
Barry McDonald
And what years what years are we talking about?
-
10:35
Speaker 2
Would have started in third class in 1963,
-
10:38
and I left school in 1972,
-
10:41
Barry McDonald
the end of nineteen seventy two. So you really were back there in the sort of a heyday of the the almost... It was kind of slightly Dickensian almost.
-
10:48
Speaker 2
Yeah. It was changing then. I think the fifties was probably your Went to town. Your high day... Heyday. Yeah. Yeah. But we were rebellious.
-
10:56
So the the the cultural revolution was in full swing in my later years of high school, you know.
-
11:02
So '67 was when I began high school.
-
11:05
'67 to '72 was pretty,
-
11:08
turbulent
-
11:09
years for younger people.
-
11:12
And so we were very
-
11:14
rebellious at school. It was war. Absolute war. And they were the authority.
-
11:19
Yeah.
-
11:20
They were fighting a rearguard action, I think. And... And they were on a losing... They were they were tenacious. They they fought hard. The the Irish were good fighters. Yes. And were they in the the cassocks? Were they were your old priests? Yep. Yep. Yep. They were brothers. Yeah. They were all in there. I think satans, they called them.
-
11:36
Yes. They dressed up in satans, and,
-
11:39
yeah, they were violent and, twisted
-
11:42
men, many of them.
-
11:44
There were some saintly men as well.
-
11:47
Barry McDonald
But you still came out of that whole,
-
11:50
you you know, you came into adulthood with an appreciation of of of this this appreciation for the Irish culture within bush music.
-
11:58
Yeah. It wasn't like you rejected it outright like a lot of people might do. No.
-
12:03
Speaker 2
And, you know, I've been cultivating
-
12:05
this connection with Ireland for lots of reasons
-
12:08
that I won't go into now, but deep sort of ancestral,
-
12:12
even spiritual reasons.
-
12:15
And, last year,
-
12:17
someone
-
12:19
alerted me to a website called Broken Rights, you may know of it,
-
12:23
which,
-
12:25
you know, lists
-
12:26
and provides
-
12:28
background detail for
-
12:30
all the cases,
-
12:33
that are pending
-
12:34
against
-
12:35
and convictions already, you know, achieved
-
12:38
against priests and brothers and lay Catholic
-
12:41
teachers
-
12:42
in Catholic schools
-
12:43
against
-
12:44
students,
-
12:46
sexual
-
12:47
molestation, whatever.
-
12:49
And I have to say that nearly every name was Irish,
-
12:54
and it was so disturbing to
-
12:56
to come across that, and it had really upset my,
-
13:00
you know, the confidence in wishing to identify with this
-
13:05
culture. Mhmm. But I I guess that's just the dark side of...
-
13:08
That has to be acknowledged and, you know, I've got River it a little bit, got used to it,
-
13:13
but, you know, the picture is never always rosy, you know, life's too complex for that. I mean, it's it's a whole subject unto itself, that one, isn't it really?
-
13:23
Barry McDonald
And and
-
13:24
having recorded stuff with the forgotten Australians and and with kids who've grown up in Christian brother homes.
-
13:30
Speaker 2
Alright.
-
13:31
Barry McDonald
One thing that struck me was that not only were the conditions abhorrent
-
13:35
often,
-
13:36
but the guys who worked there, who were the officers, who were the managers, who were the Arding, had all come through homes themselves. Yes. Yeah. And they were often victims of just a perpetual system.
-
13:47
Speaker 2
Yeah.
-
13:48
Yeah.
-
13:50
So,
-
13:53
I wasn't... I I... Yeah. I don't think I've come
-
13:57
out of that unscathed at all or unscarred.
-
14:01
Interestingly, the two
-
14:03
people that... Getting back to the music
-
14:05
that I was involved,
-
14:07
chiefly
-
14:09
with,
-
14:09
you know, collecting, playing music,
-
14:13
recording music,
-
14:16
We're both,
-
14:18
Irish Catholic in
-
14:20
in sort of provenance.
-
14:21
Their heritage is... Who are we talking about here? Not Chris Sullivan. Chris Sullivan was one. Yeah.
-
14:26
Yeah. Mark Rummery, another one, even though Rummery is an English name.
-
14:30
Mark went to the de la Salle Brothers in Armidale.
-
14:33
And, I guess there are Irish,
-
14:37
ancestors in Mark's background.
-
14:40
Barry McDonald
Was there much music in your childhood? Yeah. Mum was a piano player.
-
14:44
Speaker 2
Yeah.
-
14:45
A wonderful piano player, but when she was... Before she was 40, rheumatoid arthritis wrecked her hands
-
14:52
so she couldn't play.
-
14:55
Her
-
14:56
father, I found out much later, was a fiddle player.
-
15:01
I was at my auntie Nora O'Brien's once, and
-
15:04
she's made some mention of that's the cupboard where
-
15:07
dad's fiddle used to be kept. And I was, what are you talking about?
-
15:11
And I found out that he used to play the fiddle with
-
15:14
my grandmother who played the piano. They played as a a duo just for their own entertainment. But he was from the bush. He was from Cobar.
-
15:23
It it could be that... And Burua, Cobar and Burua. Could be that he played music as a younger bloke
-
15:30
in the bush for dances, possibly. I don't know. And I asked Aunty Nora,
-
15:35
what sort of music did he play? Because he could have been any sort of a fiddle blur. He could have been a learned musician, you know, who played Paganini's
-
15:43
whatever.
-
15:44
And she said, no.
-
15:46
He played the Irish chick, whatever that is. But, you know, I took it to mean he played,
-
15:53
you know, music learned by ear from, you know, other older people.
-
15:58
Barry McDonald
So you began
-
16:00
the recording process. I won't call it collecting. You began this recording process around,
-
16:04
in the, what, the '79?
-
16:07
Speaker 2
Yep. Yep. Well, it would have... Probably that that was when I was first introduced to,
-
16:12
you know, actual bush musicians.
-
16:17
'eighty two or 'eighty three, possibly,
-
16:20
was when I began to be active
-
16:23
myself
-
16:24
in recording, seeking out musicians,
-
16:27
Barry McDonald
travelling, recording. And how did you go about it?
-
16:31
Speaker 2
Well, it was self funded.
-
16:35
Radio two ARM
-
16:38
loaned me secondhand tapes and a Bundarra a Ua tape recorder, I think,
-
16:44
and five inch spools
-
16:46
that use...
-
16:47
Five inch spools. Five or
-
16:49
seven?
-
16:50
Seven, maybe. I don't know. Anyway,
-
16:52
and, I mean, I would travel by train. I didn't have a car.
-
16:56
So I traveled by train to Gaira, for example,
-
17:00
to see people up there. Can't remember how I got to Eralow. Later, I did have a car, and I I, traveled by car.
-
17:08
How I would find people, word-of-mouth.
-
17:10
So one one musician would tell him of another one. You should go and see such and such. I reckon you must have been pretty passionate about this then, I think so.
-
17:21
I don't know why. I love music. I think I'm pretty passionate about music
-
17:26
even though I don't know why. Again,
-
17:30
I always seem to come back to it even though sometimes I think,
-
17:34
it's a monk's game. I'll leave it behind. I'd, you know, I'd much prefer to spend my time doing something else or whatever. I always come back to music. So there's something there,
-
17:46
that keeps me interested
-
17:48
and focused.
-
17:50
I also... I lived in the house next door to Russell Ward,
-
17:53
who is a famous,
-
17:55
was a famous Australian historian,
-
17:58
who did his share of folk music collecting and
-
18:02
actually edited the first Penguin Book of Australian Ballads.
-
18:07
And Russell
-
18:09
encouraged
-
18:10
me, on the one hand, to collect
-
18:13
music.
-
18:15
Songs were his main deal, and I was interested in both instrumental music and songs.
-
18:21
But Russell also... I I had a young child.
-
18:25
Kate and I had a son.
-
18:27
He also said, wait till your family's grown up before you continue doing it because, really,
-
18:32
your family is your number one priority, and you don't wanna take time out from them. I'm glad I'd ignored his advice
-
18:38
Yeah. Because they still haven't grown up. No.
-
18:44
So you're living next to him? I was living next door. Where was that? In Armidale, Beattie Street, Armadale.
-
18:50
And,
-
18:51
an interesting,
-
18:53
I remember talking to Russell one day and and asking him
-
18:57
about the people that he recorded
-
18:59
in the nineteen fifties and nineteen sixties,
-
19:02
and he said there was one bloke who had a very interesting fragment of an... A thunderbolt song, only four lines,
-
19:09
but thunderbolt songs didn't exist from the field. You know, plenty of people have written them,
-
19:15
but actual... What he would call genuine folk songs, we better leave that definition out of contention for the
-
19:22
moment, and we don't wanna get bogged down in that area.
-
19:26
But genuine authentic folk songs just didn't really exist except for these odd fragments. And this one fellow by the name of Bill Mann
-
19:35
furnished,
-
19:37
Russell with a, a fragment of four lines.
-
19:40
And he said, there is this bloke, Bill Mann at Walker, but it... There's no way he could be alive now. Well, the next time I went down to Walker, I made inquiries, and sure enough, Bill was still alive.
-
19:50
And I went to see Bill, and he gave me the whole song.
-
19:54
So twenty five years later, what
-
19:57
was a four line fragment from Russell
-
19:59
became a Kentucky,
-
20:03
addition to
-
20:04
the Australian corpus, you know, for me. Now why he remembered better later
-
20:10
is anybody's guess, but it could have been that age brought that long term memory into the foreground, you know.
-
20:19
And I don't know how many people I recorded over the years, but I I tried to comb the table lens.
-
20:27
So I traveled, North of Armidale and South of Armidale,
-
20:31
west and east,
-
20:36
in the little torrent and cleanliness.
-
20:39
Not much in Tenterfield. A little bit in Tenterfield. No. I've got a... I lie. Yes. Tenterfield.
-
20:46
Uralla,
-
20:47
Kingstown,
-
20:50
Walker,
-
20:53
around Armadale itself,
-
20:56
and
-
20:57
maybe 60 or 70
-
20:59
people I recorded.
-
21:01
And the thing that... Why I feel ashamed about... I I mentioned that I felt ashamed about aspects of my
-
21:08
recording
-
21:09
earlier on was that
-
21:11
people naturally
-
21:15
expected that I was entering into relationship with them. They didn't know they were one of 70,
-
21:20
you know, or a 150
-
21:22
people that I'd been to see,
-
21:25
to talk about music and record their music.
-
21:28
And if I didn't get back to see them, you know,
-
21:31
from year to year, let's say,
-
21:33
they were,
-
21:35
understandably
-
21:36
puzzled.
-
21:37
Why have you abandoned me? I mean, why did you initiate this relationship
-
21:40
and then withdraw?
-
21:43
What... What's all this about?
-
21:45
That's what I'm ashamed about. Yeah.
-
21:48
Which is almost written into
-
21:51
the the job of the
-
21:54
oral historian, isn't it?
-
21:56
I guess so.
-
21:57
I guess so.
-
21:59
But when I look back on it, if if that's the case, then I did... I wouldn't want to be involved in that. So if you had your time again, you'd you'd go about it differently?
-
22:08
Yes.
-
22:09
I I I wonder. Yeah. I don't know what I'd do,
-
22:13
if I had my time again. But in more recent times,
-
22:17
I have been involved in recording relationships,
-
22:21
not musical
-
22:22
relationships, but
-
22:23
historical or philosophical or
-
22:27
ethnographical, whatever it might be, and they are one on one relationships,
-
22:31
and they are deep relationships that I maintain.
-
22:35
So that's what I'm doing now, and
-
22:38
I wouldn't revert to the the the earlier format, I suppose.
-
22:43
Having said that, I don't want to, you know, deny that it happened
-
22:47
nor that maybe there was some value in it as well.
-
22:51
It's just one of these paradoxes that you have to sit within, I guess.
-
22:56
I'm not gonna cry about it but, you know, I have to acknowledge that, you know, I feel
-
23:01
reasonably badly about certain aspects.
-
23:06
Barry McDonald
Well, I guess too that if you, you know, if you put your priorities in maintaining that relationship,
-
23:13
then there is
-
23:15
there is,
-
23:18
you know, to a cynic perhaps a risk that that
-
23:21
recording or that
-
23:22
material would be lost in time to come. So that's why people would argue to to to to make it available to things like the National Library and stuff, wouldn't they? And in terms of that collecting model, you know, preserve it, keep it for future generations, you know, hand it over to to the National Archives because, you know, if you... It's all very well for you to record if it sits on a dusty shelf, but what happens if you if you pass away sort of thing? Yeah. Sure. Sure. It's lost from the public record. Absolutely. I think what needs to be done, and Kevin Bradley at the National Library
-
23:51
Speaker 2
says, you know, I'm sitting on thousands and thousands of hours of
-
23:56
recorded material in this.
-
23:58
I don't know whether I should say this.
-
24:01
He said it it has far less value
-
24:05
sitting here
-
24:06
in its present state than it would if it was developed,
-
24:11
into, you know, value added into, you know, publication or...
-
24:16
Of any sort by the people that actually recorded the material.
-
24:21
He said that's what's really valuable,
-
24:23
not this stuff sitting on the shelves in the National Library.
-
24:27
And
-
24:28
why the people who recorded the material? Because they were the ones involved in whatever relationship
-
24:33
obtained between
-
24:35
themselves and the people that they recorded.
-
24:39
So, you know, what so what what what value is the material,
-
24:45
in the future
-
24:46
to people
-
24:48
who
-
24:50
had no part in the personal relationship that
-
24:55
that created that recording.
-
24:57
Barry McDonald
Guess it's impossible to tell. Yeah. It's impossible to answer the question.
-
25:01
No. It's not. Yeah. I mean, I guess... And that's what the live... The national library is probably banking on Is that sometime down the future, this is gonna be of some value to whoever it may be. Yeah. I have a bit of a, a difference of opinion with the library.
-
25:15
Speaker 2
So I guess my attitude to my own recording,
-
25:20
is all of a piece with my attitude
-
25:23
towards
-
25:24
the material sitting,
-
25:26
in an archive,
-
25:28
and being made available to whoever wants to hear it or see it for whatever purposes they wanna put put material to.
-
25:35
Because this
-
25:37
these are expressions
-
25:38
of,
-
25:39
I guess broadly speaking,
-
25:42
people's
-
25:43
relatedness to their world.
-
25:46
And in very, very few instances is that material gonna be used
-
25:51
in a way that will honor that.
-
25:53
So
-
25:55
that's where I differ from
-
25:58
others,
-
26:02
because I think that it's it's commodified.
-
26:06
And and that's my problem is the commodification
-
26:09
of this stuff.
-
26:11
Barry McDonald
And the the process of commodification was something that I had a part in. Okay? As in going out and collecting Yeah. Where you're using that relationship as a ways to sort of, you know, further this collection. Yeah. Let's say. Whereas now you've got a change. You've sort of got a big turn and you're much more interested in that honoring and that ongoing relationship. But seeing what the real story is, I mean, those people weren't created and, you know, put on earth to provide
-
26:36
material for a collector. Yeah. They were put on earth to to to do what they love and to celebrate that and for them to have that honored. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Something like that. I don't wanna be I don't wanna sound too preachy about it, and I don't wanna sound,
-
26:50
Speaker 2
yeah.
-
26:52
Okay. I'll leave it at that. I don't wanna sound too preachy about it. But it is...
-
26:57
I am genuine in my
-
26:59
attitude towards this stuff, you know, and I practice what my... What I preach now,
-
27:05
Barry McDonald
hopefully, you know. So, I mean, it'd be nice to kinda come back to who you actually
-
27:11
were involved in in in Arding, but I mean today
-
27:16
in a contemporary light,
-
27:18
you're very involved in sort of the nurturing of those sort of ongoing relationships
-
27:22
where it's about honoring people's
-
27:26
wisdom, tradition, experiences, memories, connections with land, all of that sort of stuff. And
-
27:32
how do you make a living out of this?
-
27:34
Speaker 2
I'm a teacher.
-
27:36
Yeah. So I'm paid to travel to remote places to teach
-
27:41
on Aboriginal communities.
-
27:43
That's how I make the living Bundarra the relationships
-
27:46
Barry McDonald
come along. And how did you make a living from it when you were initially, you know, collecting the stuff back in the the eighties?
-
27:52
Speaker 2
The music stuff?
-
27:55
Well, I was a school teacher then, I think. Yeah.
-
28:00
After a while, I was a student,
-
28:02
so I was, you know, earning off study
-
28:04
or not earning it as the case may be. But then I qualified as a high school teacher. So... Yeah.
-
28:11
Barry McDonald
How old were you when you became a high school teacher?
-
28:13
Speaker 2
31.
-
28:14
Barry McDonald
Yeah. Yeah. So that's been your bread and butter? Yep. Yeah.
-
28:19
Speaker 2
Teaching's my... Yeah. I've been doing it for twenty
-
28:21
six years. Yeah.
-
28:23
Barry McDonald
Mhmm. Yeah. So who did you come across in terms of, you know, the stuff that you you documented that you recorded?
-
28:29
Speaker 2
Musical. Righto.
-
28:31
First and foremost, the most... Well, I'll start with your Ella because this is where we are.
-
28:37
Some wonderful musicians from around the Western Side Of Uralla,
-
28:41
Kingstown,
-
28:44
Watson's Creek,
-
28:49
Uralla itself. So there was a fellow by the name of Ben Barry,
-
28:53
who played the fiddle and accordion and sang.
-
28:56
Eric Godley, who played the accordion.
-
29:01
Alice Doran.
-
29:03
D...
-
29:04
O r a n,
-
29:06
A famous Uralla name
-
29:09
Barry McDonald
who played the accordion brilliantly. She was brilliant. Was she one of the ones that Kath Ovingon was talking to me about? Was Kath had... Know her?
-
29:18
Speaker 2
She might have met her. Yeah. Yep. Kath might have known her.
-
29:21
I did... I I did some recording work with Kath. Now I I was the the sort of odd one out in terms of doing this,
-
29:30
lightning
-
29:31
collecting work,
-
29:33
other people who had a bit more leisure than I dieback, because I had a growing family, so did they. They just organized their time differently, you know,
-
29:42
or maybe their priorities were different.
-
29:45
They entered into relationship in a better way than I did. Alright? So Chris Sullivan, Mark Rummery, Barry Rummery, as she was, Kath Avington now,
-
29:56
they would sit sometimes for days with people
-
29:59
out bush
-
30:01
and play music with them
-
30:03
Barry McDonald
and do it in a really good way. And I guess that's a real opener, isn't it? That's a door opener. If you've got an instrument and you're interested in what they're playing Yeah. There's a connection there. Yeah. Absolute connection.
-
30:16
Speaker 2
Wonderful times. We met some wonderful people.
-
30:20
So there were three from Uralla that that came to mind. Charlie Bachelor was a fiddle player that we
-
30:25
we all, Chris and Mark and Barry and I,
-
30:30
played with
-
30:31
him on many occasions over a couple of years before he passed away. He was 87 when we met him
-
30:38
and, an absolutely marvelous fiddle player and a great human being.
-
30:43
So there was a lot of cultural
-
30:46
education that went on of us, young people.
-
30:50
We're in our twenties, you know, when we were doing this work.
-
30:54
And we were learning a lot about values
-
30:58
and outlook,
-
31:00
from
-
31:02
people who'd
-
31:04
seen a lot and been through a lot and endured a lot,
-
31:07
and were now very old
-
31:09
and had a pretty interesting
-
31:12
orientation, you know, to share with us. And that went in. You know, we listened.
-
31:16
We changed ourselves.
-
31:18
Barry McDonald
Do you think that, you know, the likes of people like Charlie Bachelor, you said he was in his eighties when you met
-
31:24
Speaker 2
him. So we're talking you... This was probably nineteen eighties Bundarra eighties when you you were... Yeah. But most of these older people were born at the turn of the twentieth century or before.
-
31:34
Barry McDonald
Do you think that, you know, written into their experience and their music and
-
31:39
is is this,
-
31:41
this piece of the Australian puzzle which had otherwise been sort of conveniently overlooked sometimes?
-
31:47
Speaker 2
I think so. Those others would say that it's been
-
31:50
overemphasized.
-
31:52
So I've been criticized
-
31:54
by,
-
31:55
oral historians, for example. There was one who worked at the University of New England who said, why aren't you collecting
-
32:01
from people in the Spanish tobacco grown community from South Of Tenterfield,
-
32:07
or why not the Italian community
-
32:09
here or there?
-
32:11
And that's a good question, you know.
-
32:14
My response was that, you know, we... We've we've set the parameters of the
-
32:19
the material that we're interested in collecting,
-
32:24
and that's why we... We're not interested in the other stuff. But yeah. So if you were to encapsulate,
-
32:30
Barry McDonald
you know,
-
32:31
in in... Into words
-
32:33
some of the the spirit or the flavor of kind of what it is that you see as those...
-
32:39
Speaker 2
Well, what the parameters were were were I guess,
-
32:43
there was a dominant culture. There was a, you know, a uniformity
-
32:48
about the musical expression. There were the the sorts of dances that were danced and the tunes that accompanied them, the sort of songs, the subject matter
-
32:57
of...
-
32:58
You know, they were... You could you could see the uniformity throughout
-
33:03
Barry McDonald
Australia, you know. What is it? What sort what sort are we talking about?
-
33:07
Speaker 2
Jigs, polkas? Oh, yeah. Jigs, polkas,
-
33:11
the set dances, which are the same as American square dances
-
33:14
except done less flamboyantly.
-
33:18
You've got,
-
33:20
Vasaviana,
-
33:21
Mazurka.
-
33:23
You've got
-
33:25
reels,
-
33:27
step dances.
-
33:29
That's about the
-
33:30
size of it. The instrumentation was pretty well,
-
33:34
restricted to fiddle, concertina, and accordion.
-
33:39
The songs were...
-
33:41
Oh, you get all sorts of songs,
-
33:43
but the local... Locally grown songs were, you know, were written about
-
33:48
local material, rural
-
33:51
Barry McDonald
subjects. So they're bringing
-
33:53
this tradition which has come from Ireland, which is where the music and the dance is kind of hand in glove. Ireland, England. Ireland, England. Scotland.
-
34:01
Speaker 2
Yeah. And... The the the English,
-
34:04
influence is underemphasized
-
34:06
normally.
-
34:07
But the English... If if we were to
-
34:11
compare the Australian
-
34:12
corpus
-
34:13
with
-
34:15
those from
-
34:16
Ireland, England and Scotland, the similarities with England would be most marked, not with the other two, I believe. And I did
-
34:24
a I did a research trip over to Europe
-
34:27
to listen to material in the foundry archives in those places
-
34:31
to make... To come up with that judgment.
-
34:33
Barry McDonald
And how important were those dances with the music?
-
34:36
Because there's a a range of different dances which goes with Irish music, isn't there?
-
34:42
Speaker 2
Yes. Well, yeah. Well, that was personal to people. So a community may be used to hearing a particular tune played for a particular dance and they demand that,
-
34:52
Barry McDonald
but in another community it might be a different tune to that dance. But the set dancing was very much from, you know, Ireland, Scotland, England wasn't it?
-
35:00
Speaker 2
The set Arding, it it it's a commercial thing. A lot... There's also a commercial
-
35:06
cultural
-
35:07
influence
-
35:08
on what you find out in the bushier,
-
35:11
or what you found out in the bushier. The bush dancing?
-
35:15
Yeah. So set dancing for example. So the quadrills we're talking about,
-
35:20
quadrills were a ballroom
-
35:22
creation of dancing masters,
-
35:24
you know. There was a fad, a craze, you know, and people were
-
35:29
composing dances,
-
35:32
and they've... That filtered down into the bush like it did into the countryside of Ireland and Scotland and England.
-
35:39
Barry McDonald
And
-
35:39
to what extent was it still here when you came to to Europe? The dancing wasn't happening anymore,
-
35:45
Speaker 2
but there were,
-
35:46
well,
-
35:48
that's not a 100% true. I did attend
-
35:51
a couple of dances.
-
35:53
They have changed
-
35:54
significantly,
-
35:57
but they're, you know, nowhere near... Held as frequently as they used to be. They they weren't the lifeblood of the community as they once were,
-
36:07
but then community life had changed a great deal,
-
36:11
since the nineteen twenties, let's say, when we're talking about when these
-
36:16
older musicians were really active as musicians in their communities.
-
36:21
And there were all sorts of changes and all sorts of reasons for those changes.
-
36:27
Barry McDonald
And there were... It was a huge itinerant population around areas like this, wasn't there? She was. Yeah. But there were also,
-
36:35
Speaker 2
you know, there was also a lot of stability
-
36:38
in small
-
36:40
communities.
-
36:41
There were lots of small communities, you know,
-
36:43
and there were musicians in every community,
-
36:46
dances held in every community.
-
36:48
It's amazing how,
-
36:51
to to find what we found about,
-
36:54
you know, the,
-
36:58
universality
-
36:59
of musical,
-
37:01
not talent, but ability.
-
37:04
People in every community could play a violin or a mouth organ. Mouth organ's another one I didn't mention.
-
37:10
Or an accordion, yeah. Did you did you see...
-
37:14
Music played a huge part, playing music
-
37:17
played a much bigger part in people's lives then
-
37:20
than later.
-
37:22
Barry McDonald
But you... I mean, you're really documenting in some ways the demise of it as well as you are the collection of it. Absolutely.
-
37:28
And is there a sadness around that sense that it's
-
37:32
dissipated?
-
37:34
Did you feel that with the people you were... Absolutely. Yep. Yep.
-
37:37
Speaker 2
Oh, absolutely. I I remember
-
37:39
knocking on one bloke's door
-
37:41
who's... I was recommended...
-
37:43
Who was recommended to me as a great fiddle player. I knocked on his door. I explained who I was and what I was interested in. He said it's all gone now, mate. It's all gone. And I closed
-
37:54
the door in my face.
-
37:55
There was a passion in. You know, there was, yeah, great feeling in. Yeah. You know? And people... Other people had been abandoned. They felt abandoned, you know, so they'd been...
-
38:07
Their their skills,
-
38:09
were in demand
-
38:11
at one point in a, you know,
-
38:13
insinuated right in the middle of this community life at its most joyful.
-
38:18
And, then all of a sudden, you know,
-
38:21
bands from town started... Jazz bands started going out to the bush communities.
-
38:26
Radio came in, all the rest of it, whatever,
-
38:30
might have rung the changes,
-
38:32
and they weren't needed anymore. They were they'd lost their identity, they'd, you know, lost their
-
38:38
Barry McDonald
usefulness in a sense, in a cultural sense and that was very sad for them there. A sense that there was some dignity and respect and recognition of the skills that they had. Yeah.
-
38:48
Speaker 2
Yeah. And I guess they lamented the the passing of the good old times as well and the fun that they'd had and
-
38:54
Barry McDonald
the closeness that that they'd shared. I mean, that music would have been the the the conduit for, you know, untold,
-
39:02
you know, you
-
39:03
know, love affairs and bringing the communities together
-
39:07
and socializing
-
39:08
and then and then that would have been the key to kind of, you know, if you're a man on your own, you know, coming in and Arding people. And I mean, probably very wound up with drinking as well, I'd imagine. Yeah. Their drinking wasn't tolerated in
-
39:22
Speaker 2
halls, let's say, or houses,
-
39:24
but people had their grog planted
-
39:27
outside and they'd go and, you know,
-
39:30
But it probably meant that they couldn't get as drunk as they normally would if they had
-
39:35
constant access to their
-
39:37
grog.
-
39:38
Yeah.
-
39:40
But it was... It it it was... Yeah. I never heard much about drunkenness at at, dances.
-
39:48
It just wasn't. Maybe the drinkers stayed outside, I don't know, and didn't participate that much. They were more interested in the grog than the the music.
-
39:59
Barry McDonald
Alright. So I I did look, I just feel like we've kind of touched it. We've just just touched on something and it it's something which
-
40:07
for the purpose of this, it probably needs to sort of finish around here. Okay. Otherwise, we could just go for hours. Yeah. No worries. I I feel like that. Okay.
-
40:17
Yeah.
-
40:18
Speaker 2
No worries.
-
40:20
The Aboriginal
-
40:22
involvement in this music is an interesting story as well. Is that another conversation? That's another conversation. Do you wanna have that conversation?
-
40:29
Barry McDonald
I'd be happy to. Yeah. Alright. Okay. Why don't we leave it there? Okay. Okay.